Vegan Pizza West Village: Yes, you can get proper vegan pizza in the West Village without making your friends eat somewhere sad. Two Boots West Village, at 101 7th Ave S by Sheridan Square, has eight vegan pies on the menu, all but one made with Daiya non-dairy cheese, plus a Vegan Calzone and a handful of sides that are actually labeled vegan.

This one is written for a specific person. You’re the vegan in a group of five heading out for a Saturday night in the Village, maybe a show at one of the theaters or a comedy set off Bleecker St, and you’ve been elected to “figure out food” because everyone assumes you’re the picky one.

Fine. Let’s make you the hero of the night. The pie list is the easy part; the trick is knowing what else on the table you can eat and what will quietly ambush you.

Key Takeaways

  • Two Boots West Village (101 7th Ave S, at Sheridan Square) has eight vegan pies plus a Vegan Calzone, almost all with Daiya non-dairy cheese.
  • Beyond the pies, the Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and Basil Pesto dippers and the House Salad are labeled vegan. Garlic Knots and the sliders are not.
  • For a group with one vegan, order one whole vegan pie rather than hoping for a vegan slice; which vegan pies are out by the slice changes through the day.
  • The shop stays open late on weekends, so it works for before the show and after it.

Check Out Our Menu!

Vegan Pizza West Village Lineup: Which Pie Should You Order?

Order the V for Vegan if you want the classic, the VCBGB or Vegan Cleo if you want protein, and the Earth Mother if you’d rather skip fake cheese altogether. That covers most moods. The rest of the list is for people who already know what they like.

Here’s the full vegan pie lineup at Two Boots West Village, straight from the menu.

Pie What’s on it Pick it if…
V for Vegan Artichokes, red onions, wild mushrooms, a criss-cross of sweet red pepper pesto and basil pesto, Daiya You want the house vegan signature and some color on the plate
Earth Mother Organic fresh spinach, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, wild mushrooms, red onion, marinara, no cheese at all You don’t love vegan cheese, or you want the lightest pie on the list
The VCBGB Vegan chicken, broccoli, garlic, basil pesto, Daiya You miss The CBGB and want something filling before a long night
Vegan Cleo Vegan sausage, roasted peppers, red onion, Daiya Your meat-eating friends keep eyeing your plate
Super Vegan Broccoli, artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil and sweet red pepper pestos, Daiya and vegan ricotta You want the loaded one
Vegan Tony Clifton Wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya You like sweet and savory together
Vegan Larry Tate Organic fresh spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, vegan ricotta, Daiya You want a garlicky white-pie feel
Vegan Mr. Pink Vegan chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, Daiya You want protein without pesto

Our pick for a first visit is the Vegan Cleo. It’s the one that converts skeptics, because sausage, peppers and onion is a combination everybody already trusts, and the vegan sausage carries it.

The plant-based protein on the VCBGB, Vegan Cleo and Vegan Mr. Pink comes from Be-Hive, according to the Two Boots FAQ.

The Earth Mother deserves a word on its own. It’s the only one with no cheese, which makes it the pie to order for anyone who finds Daiya too rich. The menu lists it in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes.

Every one of these sits on the same cornmeal crust as every other pie in the shop, so nobody at your table gets the “lesser” pizza.

Is there a vegan pie of the month in November?

Every November, for World Vegan Month, Two Boots teams up with a local vegan food vendor on a featured vegan pie, according to the Two Boots FAQ. Ask at the 7th Ave South counter whether it’s on while you’re there.

What Else on the Two Boots Menu Is Vegan, and What Isn’t?

Besides the pies and the Vegan Calzone, four dippers and the House Salad are labeled vegan on the Two Boots menu. Garlic Knots and the sliders are not. This is the part most vegan pizza guides skip, and it’s where dinner goes wrong.

Picture the scene. Someone orders “a few sides for the table,” the Garlic Knots land, and you’re left watching. Here’s what you can and can’t reach for.

Item Vegan? Note
Vegan Calzone Yes Daiya and vegan ricotta, with a side of marinara
Marinara dipper Yes Labeled vegan
Basil Pesto dipper Yes Labeled vegan
Sweet Red Pepper Pesto dipper Yes Labeled vegan
Jalapeño Pesto dipper Yes Labeled vegan, and marked spicy
House Salad Yes Organic mixed greens, chickpeas, red onion, shredded carrot
Garlic Knots No Made with butter and Parmigiano
Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm, Eggplant Parm sliders No All come with mozzarella
Hot Knots Ask Not labeled vegan on the menu, so check before ordering
Bombinis Ask Savory Cajun hand pies sold at the Manhattan shops; not labeled vegan
Gluten-Free Brownie, chocolate chip cookie Not labeled vegan Ask the counter rather than assume

The dippers are your secret weapon. Order a Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and a Basil Pesto for the table and suddenly your crusts are the best thing anyone’s dunking.

The Eggplant Parm slider catches people out. It sounds like the vegetable option, and it is vegetarian, but the mozzarella rules it out for you.

Bombinis are a fun extra for the meat-eaters in your crew, since the West Village is one of the few Two Boots shops that carries them. Don’t count them as part of your meal.

What about drinks?

The drinks list is simple. Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke or Pepsi, and water. There’s no beer on the menu, which suits a group that’s grabbing dinner before heading somewhere else for the night.

Vegan Pizza West Village

Can You Get a Vegan Slice, or Should a Mixed Group Order a Whole Pie?

For a group of four or five with one vegan, order one whole vegan pie for the table. Don’t plan the night around a single vegan slice. Two Boots does sell pizza by the slice, but which vegan pies are out by the slice changes, so a whole pie is the only order you can count on.

There’s a second reason, and it’s social. A whole vegan pie on a mixed table gets eaten by everyone. Order one Vegan Cleo and you’ll watch two “I’m not vegan, but” friends take a slice each.

That means you need a little more vegan pizza than you’d think. Here’s how we’d split a mixed order in the West Village.

Group Vegan eaters What to order
4 friends 1 One vegan pie (Vegan Cleo or V for Vegan) plus one classic like Grandma Bess
5 friends 1 One vegan pie, one Cleopatra Jones, one Bayou Beast for whoever wants heat
6 friends 2 Two different vegan pies, one classic, House Salad for the table
NYU dorm floor, 10 or so 2 to 3 Two vegan pies (one of them the cheese-free Earth Mother), three regular pies, vegan dippers

If you do want a vegan slice in Greenwich Village before a show, ask at the counter what’s out. If something vegan is ready, great. If not, a small whole pie is the move.

One more thing goes wrong with mixed orders. People split a pie half vegan and half regular to “save money,” and the halves end up sharing a box. Order the vegan pie as its own pie, in its own box, and keep it on your side of the table.

Can I make any Two Boots pie vegan?

The menu has a Create Your Pizza option, but stick with the eight vegan pies listed. They’re built around Daiya and vegan ricotta from the start, and the vegan takes on The CBGB, Cleopatra Jones, Tony Clifton, Larry Tate and Mr. Pink already cover most of the regular favorites.

Where to Eat Your Plant-Based Pizza Around Sheridan Square

Two Boots sits where 7th Ave South, Christopher St, W 4th St and Grove St knot together at Sheridan Square, which puts a lot of the Village within a few minutes’ walk. That location is why it works for a group night out.

Start with the obvious. Bleecker St is a block or two away, with its row of small theaters and comedy clubs, so dinner at 7th Ave South before an early show is easy to time. The shop also stays open late on weekends, which means you can come back after the last set and do round two.

Christopher Park is across the square, and it’s part of the Stonewall National Monument, run by the National Park Service. A slice on the edge of the square, with the monument across the street, is about as West Village as dinner gets.

Walk Christopher St west and you’ll hit the Hudson River Park piers. On a mild evening that’s the best place to take a pie box, sit by the water, and watch New Jersey light up. Bring napkins. The wind off the river has opinions.

Head east instead and you’re at Washington Square Park in a short walk. NYU students know this route by heart. The NYC Parks page for Washington Square Park has the official rules if you’re planning to eat on a bench by the fountain.

The neighborhood has a long counterculture streak, and so does Two Boots, which started on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987 among the punk and arts crowd. If your group is into the history of these streets, Village Preservation has maps and stories on almost every block you’ll walk that night.

For the vegan in the group, the West Village is a forgiving place to eat out. Plenty of people around here don’t eat dairy, and a pizza shop with eight vegan pies fits right in.

Catering a Plant-Based Crowd in the West Village

For anything bigger than a dorm floor, use catering. Two Boots West Village catering is drop-off delivery with packages built around group size, it includes vegetarian and vegan options, and it needs 24 to 48 hours’ notice.

That suits a student club with a few vegans, a cast party after a Village show, or an office lunch near Hudson Square. Our rule for mixed crowds: plan one vegan pie for every three or four non-vegan pies, then bump it up by one, because the vegan pies always disappear faster than you’d expect.

Tell the team how many vegan eaters are coming when you book. It’s much easier to plan for that from the start than to scramble on the day.

Plan Your Vegan Pizza West Village Night at Sheridan Square

Here’s the order we’d place for a Village night out with one vegan in a group of five. One whole Vegan Cleo, one Grandma Bess, one Bayou Beast, a Sweet Red Pepper Pesto dipper and a House Salad, eaten at the shop or carried two minutes to Christopher Park.

That’s your vegan pizza West Village order sorted, and nobody has to ask what you’re allowed to eat. If you want the plain list of every vegan pie, our earlier guide to vegan pizza near me in the West Village has it.

Then head to 101 7th Ave S. Directions and details are on the Two Boots West Village location page.

FAQs

Is Daiya cheese dairy free?

Yes. Daiya is a non-dairy cheese, which is why Two Boots uses it on seven of its eight vegan pies. If you’d rather skip it, the Earth Mother comes with marinara and vegetables and no cheese at all.

Is the Vegan Calzone big enough to share?

The Vegan Calzone comes filled with Daiya and vegan ricotta, with marinara on the side for dipping. For one hungry person it works as a meal, and for a group it’s a good extra next to a whole pie. Ask at the counter about size if you’re planning to split it several ways.

I have a dairy allergy. Is Two Boots safe for me?

Two Boots doesn’t publish a cross-contact statement, so a vegan label isn’t an allergy promise. Tell the staff about your allergy when you order so they can talk you through it, rather than relying on the vegan label alone.

Can I order vegan pizza for pickup or delivery in the West Village?

Two Boots takes online orders through Toast, and the vegan pies are on the online menu. Start from the West Village location page and check that the order is going to the 7th Ave South shop before you pay.

Why are the vegan pies named after people like Tony Clifton and Cleopatra Jones?

Every Two Boots pie is named after a pop-culture icon, and the vegan versions borrow the name of the regular pie they’re based on. So the Vegan Cleo is the plant-based take on Cleopatra Jones, and the VCBGB nods to The CBGB, the punk club era Two Boots grew up alongside in the East Village.

Are there spicy vegan options?

The Jalapeño Pesto dipper is labeled vegan and is marked spicy on the menu. Pair it with any of the vegan pies if your group wants a little heat on the plant-based side of the table.