The vegan pizza Upper West Side families can all share is on West 71st Street. Two Boots Upper West Side, at 70 W. 71st St between Columbus Ave and Central Park West, has eight vegan pies made with Daiya non-dairy cheese (one skips cheese entirely), plus a Vegan Calzone, four vegan dippers and a vegan House Salad.
This one is for a specific family: two parents, a younger kid who’d eat a cheese slice off the floor, and a fifteen-year-old who went vegan in September and now reads every menu like a contract lawyer. It’s Saturday. You’ve just done four hours of dinosaurs at the Natural History Museum, and everyone is hungry at once.
We already have a list of our vegan pies for the Upper West Side. This post goes further: the whole order, what else on the menu is vegan, what isn’t, and how to split a table so the teenager doesn’t spend dinner picking at garlic knots they can’t eat.
Key Takeaways
- Two Boots Upper West Side has eight vegan pies with Daiya (Earth Mother has no cheese at all) and a Vegan Calzone with Daiya and vegan ricotta.
- Beyond pizza, the menu marks four dippers and the House Salad as vegan. Garlic Knots and the sliders are not vegan, and Hot Knots aren’t labeled vegan, so ask.
- For a table with one vegan, order a whole vegan pie, not a vegan slice. Which vegan pies are out by the slice changes, so ask at the counter.
- Every November, Two Boots runs a featured vegan pie with a local vegan food vendor for World Vegan Month. Ask at the counter whether it’s on at 71st St.
Check Out Our Menu!
Vegan Pizza Upper West Side Lineup: Which Pie Should Your Table Order?
The short version: at Two Boots Upper West Side, the Super Vegan is the pick for a hungry teenager, the Earth Mother is the pick for anyone who doesn’t want fake cheese, and the VCBGB or Vegan Cleo is the pick for someone who misses meat.
All eight vegan pies use Daiya non-dairy cheese except the Earth Mother. Three of them carry plant-based proteins, which the Two Boots FAQ says come from Be-Hive. They’re vegan twins of pies the rest of your family probably already knows.
| Vegan pie | What’s on it | Pick it if… |
|---|---|---|
| V for Vegan | Artichokes, red onions, wild mushrooms, a criss-cross of sweet red pepper pesto and basil pesto, Daiya | You want the house classic and the pesto stripes are half the point |
| Earth Mother | Organic fresh spinach, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, wild mushrooms, red onion, marinara, no cheese | Your vegan doesn’t like dairy-free cheese, or wants the lightest pie on the list |
| The VCBGB | Vegan chicken, broccoli, garlic, basil pesto, Daiya | Someone at the table orders The CBGB and the vegan wants the same thing |
| Vegan Cleo | Vegan sausage, roasted peppers, red onion, Daiya | The meat-eaters are getting Cleopatra Jones and you want a matching pie |
| Super Vegan | Broccoli, artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil pesto, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya, vegan ricotta | One pie has to feed a very hungry person after a museum day |
| Vegan Tony Clifton | Wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya | Mushroom people, full stop |
| Vegan Larry Tate | Organic fresh spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, vegan ricotta, Daiya | You want something closer to a white pie |
| Vegan Mr. Pink | Vegan chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, Daiya | A simple protein pie without a pile of vegetables |
Our position: if you can only get one vegan pie, get the Super Vegan. It’s the only pie with both pestos, the Daiya and the vegan ricotta, and the shiitakes give it some weight. A fifteen-year-old who has been walking the dinosaur halls all morning needs weight.
The Earth Mother is the sleeper. With marinara and no cheese at all, it tastes the most like the vegetables on it, and the menu shows it in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes.
Every vegan pie comes on the same cornmeal crust as every other pie on the menu.
What Else on the Menu Is Vegan (and What Isn’t)?
Besides the pies, the Two Boots menu labels six more things as vegan: the Vegan Calzone, four dippers and the House Salad. A few popular sides are not vegan, and those are the ones that catch people out.
This is the part most “vegan pizza near me” pages skip. They tell you a shop has a vegan pie and stop there. Then your kid orders the knots everybody else is eating and finds out about the butter the hard way.
| Item | Vegan? | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Vegan Calzone | Yes | Daiya and vegan ricotta, with a side of marinara |
| Marinara dipper | Yes | Labeled vegan on the menu |
| Sweet Red Pepper Pesto dipper | Yes | Labeled vegan |
| Basil Pesto dipper | Yes | Labeled vegan |
| Jalapeño Pesto dipper | Yes | Labeled vegan and also marked spicy |
| House Salad | Yes | Organic mixed greens, chickpeas, red onion, shredded carrot |
| Garlic Knots | No | Made with butter and Parmigiano |
| Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm, Eggplant Parm sliders | No | All have mozzarella |
| Hot Knots | Ask | Not labeled vegan on the menu |
| Gluten-Free Brownie, chocolate chip cookie | Don’t assume | Neither is labeled vegan |
The dippers are the easiest upgrade nobody thinks about. Order the Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and the Basil Pesto for the crust ends, and the vegan at the table gets a side that’s theirs, not a sad leftover.
The Eggplant Parm slider is the one that trips up vegetarian-adjacent families. It’s meat-free. It is also covered in mozzarella.
Dessert is the gap. The menu doesn’t label either dessert vegan, so we won’t either. Plan on a different stop for something sweet, or ask the counter what’s in the cookie.
Bombinis, the savory Cajun hand pies sold only at the Manhattan shops (this one included), are a fun extra for the rest of the family. They aren’t labeled vegan, so they’re not part of the plant-based order.

Vegan Slice or Whole Pie? How to Order for a Mixed Table
For a table of four with one vegan, order one whole vegan pie and let everyone else sort out their own. Don’t count on a single vegan slice.
Two Boots does sell pizza by the slice. What isn’t fixed is which vegan pies are sitting out by the slice on a given day. The slice case changes, and a Saturday afternoon on 71st St is not when you want to discover the vegan option is gone. A whole vegan pie is the sure order.
It also changes the social math. A teenager with their own pie is a teenager who can offer slices to their little brother, instead of watching three people eat garlic knots.
Here’s how we’d split common Upper West Side tables:
| Your table | What to order | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Family of four, one vegan teen | A 14″ Super Vegan plus a pie for the rest (Grandma Bess or Cleopatra Jones) | The vegan eats well and has leftovers for Sunday |
| Two parents, two kids, one vegan parent | A Vegan Cleo next to a regular Cleopatra Jones | Same toppings, two versions, no arguing about who got the better pie |
| Couple, one vegan, before a show | A 10″ Earth Mother and a couple of slices for the non-vegan | Light enough for a long evening in a theater seat |
| Teen sleepover, half the room vegan | One V for Vegan, one VCBGB, one The Bayou Beast for the brave | Vegan pies on one end of the table, everything else on the other |
| Grandparents visiting, one vegan grandkid | Vegan Larry Tate beside a regular Larry Tate | A simple, garlicky pie both generations recognize |
A practical note for the order itself: say “vegan” out loud for each vegan item, and keep vegan pies in their own boxes if you’re taking them home. It sounds fussy. It saves an argument on the 1 train.
If anyone at your table has a dairy allergy rather than a preference, tell the staff when you order. We don’t make allergy-safety claims, so that conversation should happen before you pay.
Plant-Based Pizza on the UWS After the Museum
The walk from the American Museum of Natural History to our door is about eight blocks: south down Central Park West from 79th Street, then a right onto West 71st. That’s short enough that a tired eight-year-old will make it and long enough that the vegan teenager will say “I’m starving” at least twice.
That walk is why this location gets so many mixed tables. The museum pulls families from all over the city, but the regulars are Upper West Side apartment families who do the museum like other people do the grocery store. They come in hungry, they come in groups, and more and more of them have one plant-based eater.
On a decent day, take the pies to go and head back to Central Park West. The Central Park Conservancy site has maps of the lawns and playgrounds just inside the park around the West 70s, which is handy when you’re carrying two boxes and a scooter. On a cold Saturday in late November, eat here.
The Saturday museum crowd isn’t the only plant-based crowd we feed. Lincoln Center is a short walk south down Columbus Ave, and the dancers, musicians and students who rehearse there order a lot of dairy-free pizza before evening performances. If that’s your night, check your hall’s door time on the Lincoln Center site and work backward. A 10″ Earth Mother leaves you comfortable for three hours in a seat.
Concert nights bring their own vegans. The Beacon Theatre is a few blocks away on Broadway, and a Vegan Mr. Pink split two ways is an easy pre-show order. Coming up from Columbus Circle, walk north on Columbus Ave past Lincoln Center and you’ll hit 71st.
And for apartment families who never leave the neighborhood on weekends: the B and C stop at 72nd St on Central Park West, a block from us, so a vegan pizza pickup fits between soccer and homework.
Catering a Plant-Based Crowd Uptown
For a group of fifteen with five vegans, catering beats ordering at the counter. Our Upper West Side shop handles drop-off catering with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, with packages built by group size and vegetarian and vegan options available.
Think school club meetings, a building’s holiday potluck, a youth orchestra break or a teen’s birthday where half the guests have opinions about dairy. Mix a couple of vegan pies (Super Vegan and Vegan Cleo cover a lot of tastes) with meat and veggie pies, and ask for the vegan ones to be marked.
Order the House Salad for the vegan table too. It’s labeled vegan, and it stops the vegan guests from having only pizza while everyone else gets sliders.
Details and quote requests are on the Upper West Side catering page. Give us the full 48 hours if it’s a big group.
Order Vegan Pizza Upper West Side Style This Saturday
Walk out of the museum, head down Central Park West to 71st, and order a whole Super Vegan before anyone looks at the slice case. If it’s still November, ask at the counter whether the World Vegan Month featured pie is on. For vegan pizza Upper West Side tables can share, with nobody stuck on a side salad for dinner, find directions and contact details on the Two Boots Upper West Side page.
FAQs
What is Daiya, and why do the vegan pies use it?
Daiya is a brand of non-dairy cheese, and it’s what Two Boots uses on seven of its eight vegan pies and in the Vegan Calzone. If your vegan doesn’t like plant-based cheese, the Earth Mother has none.
Can I make a vegan pie from Create Your Pizza?
The menu has a Create Your Pizza option, but it doesn’t spell out which bases and toppings can go vegan, so ask at the counter before you build one. The eight named vegan pies are the reliable route, and between them they cover most of the toppings people want.
What is the November vegan pie at Two Boots?
The Two Boots FAQ says that every November, for World Vegan Month, Two Boots partners with a local vegan food vendor on a featured vegan pie of the month. Whether it’s on at 70 W. 71st St on a given day is something to ask the counter about.
Who started Two Boots, and why are the pies named after people?
Phil Hartman founded Two Boots in 1987 on Avenue A in the East Village, and the name comes from the two “boots” of Italy and Louisiana. The pies are named for pop-culture icons, which is how a vegan ends up ordering a Vegan Tony Clifton or a Vegan Mr. Pink with a straight face.
What should a vegan drink with their pizza at Two Boots?
The drinks list runs to Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke, Pepsi and water. A Boylan soda next to a Vegan Cleo is a good Saturday lunch.
Is the vegan pizza on the UWS okay for someone with a dairy allergy?
Two Boots doesn’t make allergy-safety claims, and the same kitchen makes every cheese pie on the menu. If someone has a dairy allergy rather than a dietary choice, tell the staff when you order so they know before your pie is made.
