Yes, you can get proper vegan pizza in Jersey City without making your vegan friends eat a sad side salad. Two Boots at 133 Newark Ave makes eight vegan pies, most of them with Daiya non-dairy cheese, plus a Vegan Calzone, four vegan dippers and a vegan House Salad.

This guide is for one person. You rent a place in downtown JC, maybe one of the newer buildings near Hamilton Park or a walk-up off Grove Street, and you’ve got six friends coming over on Saturday. Two of them are vegan. One of them is the friend who reads every label.

You don’t need a list of vegan pies. You need a whole order that works for a mixed table, and you need to know which items on the menu will quietly trip someone up.

Key Takeaways

  • Two Boots Jersey City at 133 Newark Ave has eight vegan pies and a Vegan Calzone, made with Daiya non-dairy cheese (Earth Mother skips cheese entirely).
  • Four dippers and the House Salad are labeled vegan, so the extras can be plant-based too.
  • Garlic Knots and the sliders are not vegan, and Hot Knots aren’t labeled vegan, so ask before ordering them for the vegan side of the table.
  • For a mixed group, order at least one whole vegan pie instead of counting on a vegan slice being out.

Check Out Our Menu!

Which Vegan Pizza in Jersey City Should You Order?

Order Super Vegan if you can only get one vegan pie for the group, because it carries the most toppings of any vegan pie and adds vegan ricotta on top of the Daiya. That’s our pick for a host who wants the vegans to feel like they got the good stuff, not the leftovers.

Every vegan pie at Two Boots Jersey City sits on the same cornmeal crust as every other pie on the menu. The difference is the cheese and the proteins. Daiya handles the melt, and the vegan chicken and vegan sausage come from Be-Hive’s plant-based proteins, according to the Two Boots FAQ.

Several of these are vegan takes on meat or dairy pies the rest of your friends already know. That’s handy at a party, because the vegan and non-vegan versions can sit side by side on the counter and people can compare.

Vegan pie What’s on it Pick it if…
Super Vegan Broccoli, artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil pesto, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya, vegan ricotta You only get one vegan pie and want it loaded
V for Vegan Artichokes, red onions, wild mushrooms, a criss-cross of sweet red pepper pesto and basil pesto, Daiya Your vegan friend loves vegetables and pesto
Earth Mother Organic spinach, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, wild mushrooms, red onion, marinara, no cheese Someone at the table avoids vegan cheese too
The VCBGB Vegan chicken, broccoli, garlic, basil pesto, Daiya You want a protein-heavy pie
Vegan Cleo Vegan sausage, roasted peppers, red onion, Daiya A meat-eater might steal it, which is the point
Vegan Tony Clifton Wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya The group likes sweet onion and earthy mushroom
Vegan Larry Tate Organic spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, vegan ricotta, Daiya Garlic fans who want something lighter
Vegan Mr. Pink Vegan chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, Daiya You want a simple chicken-and-garlic pie

Earth Mother deserves a second look. It’s the one vegan pie with no cheese at all, just marinara and a heap of vegetables, and the menu lists it in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes. If one of your two vegans is also off processed cheese, that’s their pie.

Vegan Cleo is the sneaky one. It’s built on Cleopatra Jones, the sausage-and-peppers pie, and it’s the vegan pie most likely to vanish before the vegans get seconds. Order accordingly.

If you want the plain roll call of every vegan pie and its backstory, our earlier post on vegan pizza near me in Jersey City covers that. This one is about the rest of the order.

What Else at Two Boots Jersey City Is Vegan (and What Isn’t)?

Beyond the pies, the Vegan Calzone, four of the six dippers and the House Salad are labeled vegan on the Two Boots menu, while the Garlic Knots and every slider are not. That’s the part most vegan pizza roundups skip, and it’s where a well-meaning host gets caught.

Picture it. You order three pies, one vegan, then add a big box of Garlic Knots because everyone loves knots. Your vegan friends eat their two slices and watch everyone else work through the knots. Not the vibe.

Item Vegan? Note
Vegan Calzone Yes Daiya and vegan ricotta, with marinara on the side
Marinara dipper Yes The safe all-rounder
Basil Pesto dipper Yes Great with crusts from any pie
Sweet Red Pepper Pesto dipper Yes Sweet, mild, crowd favorite
Jalapeño Pesto dipper Yes Marked spicy on the menu
House Salad Yes Organic mixed greens, chickpeas, red onion, shredded carrot
Garlic Knots No Made with butter and Parmigiano
Hot Knots Not labeled vegan Ask at the counter before ordering for vegans
Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm and Eggplant Parm sliders No All come with mozzarella
Chocolate chip cookie and Gluten-Free Brownie Not labeled vegan Ask, and don’t assume
Drinks Your call Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke or Pepsi, water

The Eggplant Parm slider is the one that fools people. It sounds like the vegetarian option, and it is vegetarian. It is not vegan, because of the mozzarella.

The Vegan Calzone is the underrated move for a party. It’s one sealed item, easy to cut into wedges, and it gives your vegan friends something to eat while the pies are still being argued over. Ask for extra marinara.

Order two vegan dippers for the table and put them at the vegan end. Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and Basil Pesto both work with every crust in the room, so the meat-eaters will dip too and nobody feels like the vegans got the special-diet tray.

A word for anyone with a dairy allergy rather than a preference: the menu labels tell you what’s in a dish, not how the kitchen handles shared surfaces. Tell the staff about the allergy when you order.

How Many Vegan Pies Does a Mixed Group Need?

For a group of six to eight with two vegans, order one whole vegan pie, not one vegan slice per person. You can’t count on any particular vegan pie being out by the slice, and a whole pie means the vegans get real choice and real seconds.

Two Boots does sell pizza by the slice. Which vegan pies are on the slice counter changes, though, and we won’t promise you a specific one. If you’re grabbing for yourself, ask at the counter. If you’re hosting, get the whole pie and stop worrying.

Here’s the trade-off nobody mentions. Meat-eaters eat vegan pizza. They will try the Vegan Cleo out of curiosity and come back for another slice. If your two vegans are big eaters, or your other friends are nosy, go to two vegan pies.

Group Vegans What to order
4 friends 1 One vegan pie, one non-vegan pie, a House Salad
6 friends 2 One vegan pie, two non-vegan pies, Vegan Calzone, two vegan dippers
8 friends 2 Two vegan pies, two non-vegan pies, Garlic Knots for the non-vegans only
8 friends 4 Three vegan pies, one non-vegan pie, House Salads
Everyone vegan All Mix Earth Mother with one or two Daiya pies for variety

For the non-vegan side, pick pies that are clearly different from what the vegans are eating so nobody grabs the wrong box. The Bayou Beast (shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, marked spicy) and Grandma Bess (the thin, square Sicilian with San Marzano tomatoes) both look nothing like a vegan pie.

Do one simple thing when the boxes land: label them. A strip of tape and a marker on the lid saves your label-reading friend from opening every box.

Hosting a Plant-Based Pizza Night in Downtown Jersey City

Downtown Jersey City is built for this kind of night, because so many people live in apartments within walking distance of the Newark Avenue pedestrian plaza. If you’re near Hamilton Park, Van Vorst Park or the blocks around Grove Street, picking up a stack of boxes from 133 Newark Ave is a short carry home.

The plaza is car-free, so the walk with the boxes is the calm part. The tricky part is the elevator in your building at the same moment three neighbors are coming home. Carry the pies flat and give yourself an extra minute.

Some of your guests will come in from elsewhere. Friends who live up by Journal Square can hop on the PATH and get off at Grove Street, right by the plaza. Anyone coming from Manhattan has the same easy hop under the river. Send them the PATH service page from the Port Authority so nobody blames you for weekend track work.

If your apartment is small, take the party outside. Hamilton Park is the obvious move on a mild day, with benches and grass and enough room for a row of pizza boxes. For a bigger day out, Liberty State Park has the harbor views and the space for a real picnic; check the Liberty State Park page from NJ State Parks before you plan the trip, since it’s a longer haul than the walk to Hamilton Park.

Newark Ave is a busy public plaza, and the city’s own calendar can change what’s happening there on a given weekend. Before you pick a Saturday, the City of Jersey City website is the place to check for events and street closures that could change the scene around the plaza.

One more local note. Every November, Two Boots marks World Vegan Month by teaming up with a local vegan food vendor on a featured vegan pie of the month, per the Two Boots FAQ. We can’t promise which pie or whether it’s on at the Jersey City shop on your night. Ask at the counter, and if it’s there, add it to the order.

Should You Cater a Vegan Crowd in Jersey City?

Yes, once you’re past about a dozen people, catering beats a walk-in order. Two Boots does drop-off catering with packages sized by group, vegetarian and vegan options included, and asks for 24 to 48 hours’ notice.

That fits the downtown JC crowd well. Think of a rooftop birthday in a Newark Ave building, an office lunch near the PATH, or a building-wide potluck where half the floor is plant-based. Nobody wants to carry eight boxes up from the plaza.

The catering route also solves the labeling problem. Ask for the vegan pies to be marked or packed together, and tell them how many vegans you’re feeding so the split makes sense. Start from the Jersey City catering page to set it up.

Plan Your Vegan Pizza Jersey City Night on Newark Ave

Pick Super Vegan or Vegan Cleo as your anchor pie, add the Vegan Calzone and two vegan dippers, and leave the Garlic Knots for the meat-eaters. That’s the order that makes your two vegan friends feel like guests instead of an afterthought.

For vegan pizza in Jersey City, the Two Boots Jersey City page has the address, the ordering link and everything else you need before Saturday.

FAQs

Which Two Boots vegan pies have vegan ricotta?

Two of them: Super Vegan and Vegan Larry Tate both add vegan ricotta on top of the Daiya, and the Vegan Calzone is filled with it too. If someone in your group loves a creamy white-pie bite, point them at Vegan Larry Tate.

Can I order vegan pizza ahead for pickup on Newark Ave?

Yes. Two Boots takes online orders through Toast, so start from the Two Boots Jersey City page and check the order is going to the 133 Newark Ave shop before you pay. Ordering ahead means the vegan pies are boxed and ready when you walk over from your building.

Where do the vegan chicken and vegan sausage come from?

The Two Boots FAQ says the plant-based protein toppings come from Be-Hive. They show up on The VCBGB, Vegan Mr. Pink (vegan chicken) and Vegan Cleo (vegan sausage).

What should a vegan drink with pizza at Two Boots?

The drink fridge carries Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke or Pepsi and water. Hal’s seltzer is a good pick with the pesto-heavy pies, because it cuts through the richness.

Is any dessert at Two Boots vegan?

Neither dessert is labeled vegan. The menu has a house-baked chocolate chip cookie and a Gluten-Free Brownie, but don’t assume either one is plant-based; ask at the counter, or plan a vegan dessert of your own for the party.

Why does a pizza shop from the East Village have so many vegan pies?

Two Boots opened on Avenue A in 1987, founded by Phil Hartman in a neighborhood full of punks, artists and activists, and the menu has always leaned toward feeding that crowd. The vegan list grew from there, with vegan versions of house favorites like Cleopatra Jones and The CBGB.