It’s 7:40 on a Tuesday. You just got off a shift near York Avenue, or out of a seminar at Hunter, and the idea of a three-course anything makes you want to lie down on 2nd Ave. That’s the exact moment casual dining on the Upper East Side was invented for, and our take is simple: on a weeknight in the East 60s, a good pizza shop beats a sit-down restaurant almost every time.

Two Boots Upper East Side is at 1243 2nd Ave, between East 65th and East 66th. You walk in, you pick a pie named after a pop-culture icon, you eat it on a crisp cornmeal crust, and you’re home before the second episode starts.

This post is for the East 60s regular who eats out a few nights a week and is tired of pretending every dinner has to be an event. We’ll be honest about what casual dining gives up, then get practical: how to order for one, for two, and for six.

Key Takeaways

  • Two Boots Upper East Side at 1243 2nd Ave (between East 65th and 66th) is a casual weeknight dinner option for the East 60s: pizza, garlic knots, sliders, salads and Bombinis.
  • Casual dining trades ceremony for speed and flexibility. If you want a long, multi-course night out, book a sit-down place. For a Tuesday, pizza wins.
  • Ordering scales cleanly: a slice and a Bombini for one, two different pies for two, and a red-white-vegan split plus knots for six.
  • Bombinis, savory Cajun hand pies, are sold only at the Manhattan shops, and the Upper East Side is one of them.

Check Out Our Menu!

What Casual Dining on the Upper East Side Actually Means

Casual dining on the Upper East Side means a real dinner without the planning. There’s no dress code and no booking window to stalk. You decide on the walk home, and dinner happens soon after.

Industry people slice it finer, into “fast casual,” “casual” and “family dining.” The neighborhood doesn’t care. It cares about whether dinner fits between the subway and the couch.

Here’s our position, stated plainly. Most weeknight dinners don’t deserve a sit-down restaurant.

A sit-down meal is great for a birthday, a first date you’re serious about, or the parents in from out of town. It’s overkill for “I worked eleven hours and I need carbs.” Casual dining is the right tool for the most common dinner of the week, and pretending otherwise is how people end up spending ninety minutes on a meal they barely remember.

Casual vs. Sit-Down: The Honest Trade-Offs

Casual dining wins on speed and flexibility, and a sit-down restaurant wins on occasion and range, so they’re simply good at different nights.

We’d rather tell you where a pizza shop falls short than oversell it. So here’s the side-by-side.

What you care about Casual pizza shop (Two Boots UES) Sit-down restaurant
Decision time Minutes. Pick a pie, done Often a reservation and a plan
How long dinner takes You set the pace Paced by courses
Eating alone Completely normal Sometimes awkward at a table for two
Splitting with a group Easy: pies divide into slices Separate plates, separate checks
Mixed diets at one table Veggie, meat and vegan pies on one menu Depends on the kitchen
Taking it home Built for it Sometimes, rarely the point
Big-occasion feeling Low, and that’s fine High
Menu range Pizza, knots, sliders, salads, calzones Broader, multi-course

If the night itself is the point, go sit down somewhere; if dinner is just dinner, the left column is where you want to be.

A pizza menu has a ceiling on variety. You can eat at Two Boots three nights in a row and have three very different meals (Grandma Bess, then The Bayou Beast, then a Vegan Cleo), but it’s still pizza night three nights in a row. Some people consider that a feature.

Who Eats Casual in the East 60s

The East 60s has three crowds who live on casual dinners, and each one wants something slightly different from 2nd Ave.

Hunter College students and staff. Hunter’s main campus is a few blocks west around East 68th and Lexington. Students want something that costs them no time and fills them up between an evening class and a library session. A slice and a Bombini covers it, and the Bombini travels in a coat pocket better than most dinners do.

The York Avenue medical crowd. East of us, the hospitals and research campuses along York Avenue run on shifts that don’t line up with anyone’s dinner reservation. A nurse coming off a 12-hour shift isn’t booking a table. They want something hot, fast and filling on the walk to the train. A whole pie split with a coworker is the standard move.

Neighbors with errands. Plenty of people pass through the East 60s with shopping bags from Bloomingdale’s on Lexington and 59th, or coming off the Roosevelt Island Tram at its 2nd Ave and 60th Street station. You’re already on 2nd Ave. Six blocks north and dinner is handled.

None of them wants to commit to an evening, and all of them want to eat well and get on with it.

How to Order for One

For one person, order a slice or a small pie plus a Bombini, and skip the temptation to over-order.

The case for a small pie over slices is leftovers. Take home what you don’t finish, and tomorrow’s lunch is sorted. The case for slices is variety: two different slices means two different pies in one dinner.

Solo picks:

  • The Buckminster if you want a comfort pie: marinara on top, organic spinach, roasted garlic, parmigiano, provolone and mozzarella.
  • Mr. Pink if you’re curious about the Louisiana side: Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic and mozzarella, and it isn’t marked spicy.
  • A Bombini on the side. They’re savory Cajun hand pies, sold only at our Manhattan shops, and they’re the easiest thing on the menu to eat on the walk home.

Light appetite? A Caesar or House salad and an order of Garlic Knots (three to an order) is a full dinner that doesn’t feel like pizza.

How to Order for Two

For two people, order two different pies and split them, because you get twice the range for the same amount of food.

The trick is to pair a red pie with a white one. Red-and-white gives you contrast across the table, and it keeps the second half of the meal from tasting like the first half.

Pairings that work:

  • Grandma Bess + The Meg. Grandma Bess is organic San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil, Parmigiano and mozzarella on a thin, square Sicilian crust. The Meg is a very white pie: provolone, parmigiano, ricotta, mozzarella, roasted garlic and oregano. Classic meets creamy.
  • Cleopatra Jones + Tony Clifton. Sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers and red onions on one side; wild mushrooms, Vidalia onions and sweet red pepper pesto on the other. One meat, one veggie, both hearty.
  • The Bayou Beast + Mel Cooley. For the couple where one person wants heat and the other doesn’t. The Bayou Beast (spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños) is marked spicy. Mel Cooley (sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, basil pesto, white pie) is not.

Add a dipper for the crusts. Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and Cajun Ranch are the two we’d fight over.

How to Order for Six

For six people, order three pies in three lanes (one red, one white, one vegan) plus a side of knots or sliders.

Six is the size where casual dining really earns its keep. At a sit-down restaurant, six people means six menus, six orders and a long wait. At a pizza shop, six people means three decisions.

Lane Pick one Why it belongs on the table
Red Grandma Bess, Cleopatra Jones or Mr. Pink The safe crowd-pleaser
White The Meg, Big Maybelle or Larry Tate Something different for people who skip red sauce
Vegan V for Vegan, Vegan Cleo or Super Vegan (Daiya non-dairy cheese) The plant-based friend eats a real pie, not a side salad
Wild card The Bayou Beast, The Dude or Animal Collective The pie everyone talks about after
Sides Garlic Knots, Hot Knots, or Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm or Eggplant Parm sliders Something to eat while the pies get divided
Sweet Gluten-Free Brownie or house-baked chocolate chip cookie A small finish without ordering dessert for six

If the six includes kids, swap the wild card for a Pizza Face. It’s a small, kid-friendly face pie, and it gives a picky eater a pie that’s entirely theirs.

If six turns into twenty (an office dinner, a study group, a department send-off), that’s a catering order. Our Upper East Side catering page has the details and the request form.

Casual Dinner by Occasion on 2nd Ave

Here’s how we’d match a casual dinner to the occasion, from the quiet Tuesday to the Saturday with the whole crew.

Occasion Who’s eating What to order
Post-shift dinner One tired person from York Ave A Bombini and a slice, then home
Between Hunter classes A student with 40 minutes Two slices, or knots and a Caesar salad
Casual date Two people, low pressure Grandma Bess and The Meg, split
Roommate night in Two to three, eating on the couch One Cajun pie, one classic, one dipper each
Friends after the Tram Four to six The three-lane order plus a wild card
Saturday in the park A small group with a picnic plan Pies to go, then walk east to the river
Vegan and meat eater Two people, two diets Vegan Cleo and Cleopatra Jones, same idea both ways

For the Saturday row, walk a pie a block east to St. Catherine’s Park, on 1st Ave between East 67th and 68th. Or head uptown to Carl Schurz Park along the East River, where the benches come with a view. A pizza box on your lap counts as casual dining.

Why Pizza Is the Right Kind of Casual

Pizza is the most flexible casual dinner there is, because one order can split across people, diets and appetites without anyone getting a worse meal. Two Boots adds a couple of things that make it more than a default.

The first is the menu’s split personality. Phil Hartman opened the original Two Boots on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987, and the name comes from the two boots of Italy and Louisiana. That means you can order a straight-up Grandma Bess and a crawfish-and-andouille Bayou Beast from the same counter, which is unusual on 2nd Ave.

The second is the cornmeal crust, which gets crisp and has a bit of texture, and it holds up to heavy toppings and to the walk home.

Every pie is also named after a cultural icon, and saying “one Dude, please” at the end of a long day is good for the soul.

For the broader overview, see our guide to casual restaurants near you on the Upper East Side.

Your Casual Dining Upper East Side Night Starts at 1243 2nd Ave

Next weeknight you can’t face a reservation, walk to 2nd Ave between East 65th and 66th, order two different pies or a slice and a Bombini, and call that dinner.

That’s casual dining on the Upper East Side the way it should work: fast, flexible and genuinely good. Get directions from our locations page.

FAQs

Does Two Boots have a loyalty program?

Yes. Two Boots runs a loyalty program through Toast, the system behind our online ordering, so a few casual dinners a month on 2nd Ave can add up.

Can I build my own pie instead of ordering a named one?

Yes. The menu has a Create Your Pizza option, so you can build a pie from the toppings on offer, which is a good fallback when one person at the table has very specific opinions.

What’s a good casual dinner that isn’t pizza?

Try the sliders. Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm (made with andouille meatballs) and Eggplant Parm all come on house-made garlic knots. Add a House salad and you’ve had dinner without a single slice. There’s also a Classic Calzone and a Vegan Calzone.

Which pies are marked spicy?

The menu marks The Bayou Beast, The Bird, The Divine, Meat the Mets and Night Tripper as spicy, along with Hot Knots and the Jalapeño Pesto dipper. Everything else isn’t sold as a hot item, so a heat-shy diner has plenty of room.

What drinks go with a casual pizza dinner?

We carry Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke, Pepsi and water. A Boylan soda with a Grandma Bess is an easy, old-school pairing.

Why is it called Two Boots?

The name comes from two boot-shaped places on the map: Italy and Louisiana. Phil Hartman opened the first Two Boots on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987, and the menu still pairs Italian pizza with New Orleans Cajun flavors, which is why andouille and crawfish turn up on a 2nd Ave pie.