You’ve probably walked past 1243 2nd Ave a dozen times, somewhere in the 60s, and filed it under “pizza place.” Fair enough. But Two Boots is only half Italian. The other half is Louisiana, and if you’ve been looking for Cajun pizza on the Upper East Side, it’s been on your block the whole time: crawfish and andouille on The Bayou Beast, Creole chicken on Mr. Pink, a Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie called The Dude.
The name gives it away once you know. Italy is a boot. Louisiana is a boot. Phil Hartman opened the first Two Boots on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987, and the two boots have been sharing a crust ever since.
This guide is for the 2nd Ave neighbor who’s curious but cautious. We’ll go dish by dish through what’s actually Cajun or Creole on the menu, tell you which pie to try first (it isn’t the one you’d guess), and sort out heat, groups and kids.
Key Takeaways
- Two Boots Upper East Side at 1243 2nd Ave serves Cajun Italian pizza: Louisiana ingredients like crawfish, andouille, tasso ham and Creole chicken on an Italian-style pie with a cornmeal crust.
- Only two Cajun-leaning pies are marked spicy on the menu: The Bayou Beast and Meat the Mets. Mr. Pink, Big Maybelle and The Dude are not.
- Our pick for a first visit is Mr. Pink, then The Bayou Beast on the second trip.
- Bombinis, savory Cajun hand pies, are sold only at the Manhattan shops, and the Upper East Side is one of them.
Check Out Our Menu!
What Cajun Italian Pizza Means at Two Boots
Cajun Italian pizza at Two Boots means a familiar pizza base (red sauce or white, mozzarella, a crisp cornmeal crust) carrying ingredients and seasonings from Louisiana. It isn’t a separate menu. The Louisiana pies sit right next to Grandma Bess and Cleopatra Jones, and you order them the same way.
So what counts as “Cajun” here? On our menu it shows up in a handful of specific forms: andouille sausage, crawfish, spiced shrimp, tasso ham, Creole chicken, a Cajun Ranch dipper and the Bombinis. Some pies use one of those. The Bayou Beast uses almost all of them.
A quick word on the words. Cajun and Creole are two different Louisiana traditions, and the menu uses both. The Cajun story starts with Acadian exiles from Nova Scotia who settled in Louisiana, which the National Park Service covers at Jean Lafitte National Historical Park and Preserve. We’re a pizza shop, so we’ll leave the deeper history to them and stick to what’s on the pie.
The cornmeal crust is under everything, Cajun or not. It’s crisp, it has a bit of texture, and it’s sturdy enough to hold shrimp and crawfish without folding into a mess.
Cajun Pizza Upper East Side: The Pie-by-Pie Lineup
Here’s every pie and side on the menu with a Cajun or Creole element, what that element is, and whether the menu marks it spicy. If it doesn’t carry the spicy mark, it isn’t sold as a hot pie.
| Pie or item | Cajun or Creole element | Marked spicy? | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Bayou Beast | Spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, mozzarella | Yes | The full Louisiana experience, for people who like heat |
| The Dude | Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie: ground beef and andouille, tasso ham, cheddar, mozzarella | No | Burger people who want something new |
| Mr. Pink | Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella | No | First-timers and anyone who likes a classic red pie |
| Big Maybelle | Creole chicken, Zoe’s pepperoni, fresh garlic, white pie | No | Pepperoni fans who want to try one new thing |
| Meat the Mets | Creole chicken with sweet Italian sausage, Zoe’s pepperoni, jalapeños, ricotta, mozzarella | Yes | Big appetites who like a loaded pie with some kick |
| Meatball Parm sliders | Andouille meatballs on house-made garlic knots | No | Side order for the table, or a light meal |
| Animal Collective | Spinach-artichoke dip with a dash of cayenne, scallions, mozzarella | No | Vegetarians who want a hint of Louisiana |
| Bombinis | Savory Cajun hand pies (Manhattan shops only) | No | Eating on the go, or adding to any order |
| Cajun Ranch | A dipper for your crusts | No | Anyone who saves the crust for last |
The Bayou Beast: the whole Louisiana pantry on one pie
The Bayou Beast is the most Cajun thing we make. Spiced shrimp, crawfish and andouille all land on the same pie, with jalapeños on top and mozzarella underneath. It’s marked spicy, and the jalapeños are a big part of why.
If you’ve been searching for crawfish pizza in NYC, this is the pie. On the menu we list, it’s the only one with seafood.
The Dude: a cheeseburger that went to Louisiana
The Dude is a Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie. Ground beef and andouille, tasso ham, cheddar and mozzarella. It’s rich rather than hot, and it isn’t marked spicy, which surprises people who assume “Cajun” always means fire.
Abide accordingly.
Mr. Pink and Big Maybelle: Creole chicken two ways
Both pies are built around Creole chicken, and they take it in opposite directions. Mr. Pink puts it on a red pie with plum tomatoes and fresh garlic. Big Maybelle goes white, with Zoe’s pepperoni and garlic.
Neither is marked spicy. If you want Creole chicken pizza without committing to jalapeños, these two are the way in.
The smaller Cajun touches
Not every Louisiana note needs a whole pie. The Meatball Parm sliders use andouille meatballs on our house-made garlic knots. Animal Collective, a vegetarian pie, gets a dash of cayenne in its spinach-artichoke base. Cajun Ranch is a dipper, so any pie on the menu can borrow a little Louisiana at the crust.
Which Cajun Pie Should a First-Timer Order?
Start with Mr. Pink. We know The Bayou Beast is the headliner, and we know it’s tempting, but it’s a lot of new flavors at once, plus jalapeños, and a first-timer can’t tell which part they liked.
Mr. Pink gives you one clean read on the Louisiana side. Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, garlic, mozzarella, cornmeal crust. Everything except the chicken is familiar, so the chicken is what you taste.
Then come back for The Bayou Beast. By the second visit you’ll know what the Creole seasoning brings, and the shrimp, crawfish and andouille will make more sense as a set.
If you’re more of a burger person than a chicken person, swap Mr. Pink for The Dude. Same logic: no jalapeños, one clear Cajun idea.
And add a Bombini either way. They’re only sold at our Manhattan shops, so living near the Upper East Side location is a real advantage here. Bombinis are savory, not spicy, and they’re easy to eat while you walk home up 2nd Ave.
How Hot Is the Cajun Food at Two Boots UES?
Only the items marked with the spicy symbol on the menu are sold as spicy, and among the Cajun-leaning pies that’s The Bayou Beast and Meat the Mets. Both carry jalapeños. The rest of the Louisiana lineup (The Dude, Mr. Pink, Big Maybelle, Bombinis, the andouille meatball sliders) is not marked spicy.
That’s the part people get wrong. “Cajun” on our menu is about ingredients and seasoning, and heat is a separate choice you make.
Animal Collective is the one to read closely. It has a dash of cayenne, but the menu doesn’t mark it spicy. Think of it as warmth, not burn.
Heat seekers who want more than this post covers should read our older guide to spicy pizza on the Upper East Side, which goes through the jalapeño side of the menu in detail. This post is about flavor first.
Mixing Cajun and Classic Pies for a Group
For a group, order one Louisiana pie and one classic, not two of the same. A table of four almost never agrees, and splitting the order means the cautious eaters have a safe pie while the curious ones get to try something new.
Our go-to pairing for a mixed table is The Bayou Beast plus Grandma Bess. One spicy and loaded, one simple and familiar.
If nobody wants heat, try The Dude next to Cleopatra Jones. Both are hearty, neither is marked spicy, and the sausage people and the burger people are both covered.
Vegan in the group? There’s a Vegan Mr. Pink on our vegan list, made with Daiya non-dairy cheese, alongside V for Vegan, Vegan Cleo and Super Vegan. Ask at the counter what goes on the vegan version before you order it for someone.
Here’s how we’d order by occasion.
| Occasion | What to order | Why |
|---|---|---|
| First visit, solo | A small Mr. Pink plus a Bombini | One clear Creole flavor, one Manhattan-only extra |
| Date night, one adventurous eater | The Bayou Beast and Grandma Bess | Heat on one side, a classic on the other |
| Friends who all want to try Cajun | The Bayou Beast, The Dude and Big Maybelle | Seafood, beef and chicken covered without repeating |
| Family with young kids | Big Maybelle or Mr. Pink, plus a Pizza Face | No jalapeños, and the kids get their own small pie |
| Vegan and meat eater together | Vegan Mr. Pink and Mr. Pink | Same pie name, two versions, easy to compare |
| Office or lab lunch | Catering mix of Cajun, classic and vegan pies, plus Meatball Parm sliders | Covers most diets in one order |
Kids and Cajun Pizza
Kids can eat Cajun pizza at Two Boots without any trouble if you stick to the pies that aren’t marked spicy. Mr. Pink and Big Maybelle are the easy picks: chicken, pepperoni, garlic, cheese.
The Pizza Face is the backup plan. It’s a small, kid-friendly face pie, and it means a picky eater has something that’s entirely theirs while the adults try The Bayou Beast.
The 2nd Ave Blocks Around Two Boots UES
Two Boots Upper East Side sits on 2nd Ave in the 60s, close to Hunter College, the medical and research buildings that run toward York Avenue, and blocks of apartment buildings full of neighbors who walk past our door every day. That mix shapes who comes in and what they order.
Students from Hunter College, a few blocks west around 68th Street, tend to want one slice and a Bombini between classes. It’s a low-commitment way to try the Cajun side.
East of us, toward York Avenue, the hospitals and campuses like Rockefeller University bring a lot of teams who eat together at work. That’s who catering is built for. Drop a Bayou Beast and a Mr. Pink into a lab meeting order and the Louisiana half of the menu gets a fair hearing from a room full of skeptics.
Further north, Carl Schurz Park sits along the East River. A pie to go and a bench by the water is a very good Saturday. And on museum days, Museum Mile on Fifth Avenue pulls families uptown; a shared pie on the way home is an easy way to end the trip.
Feeding a Team the Cajun Way
For an office, a lab or a study group, catering beats a line of twelve people at the counter. The Upper East Side shop asks for at least 24 to 48 hours’ notice, and more for big events.
A balanced Cajun-curious order looks like this: one Bayou Beast for the adventurous, one Mr. Pink or Big Maybelle for everyone else, a vegan pie at the far end of the table, and a tray of Meatball Parm sliders on garlic knots.
Details and how to request a quote are on our Upper East Side catering page.
Order Your First Cajun Pie on 2nd Ave
Walk in, order a Mr. Pink and a Bombini, and save The Bayou Beast for round two. That’s the whole plan, and it’s the fastest way to find out whether the Louisiana half of Two Boots is your half.
The Cajun pizza Upper East Side neighbors have been walking past is at 1243 2nd Ave. Find directions and contact details on our locations page, then go see what the other boot tastes like.
FAQs
Is Cajun food the same as Creole food?
No. They’re two distinct Louisiana traditions, and plenty of people have spent a long time on the differences. On our menu, “Cajun” appears on The Dude, the Bombinis and the Cajun Ranch dipper, while “Creole” describes the chicken on Mr. Pink, Big Maybelle and Meat the Mets.
Does The Bayou Beast contain shellfish?
Yes. It has spiced shrimp and crawfish, along with andouille and jalapeños. If anyone in your party has a shellfish allergy, tell the counter before you order so they can talk you through the rest of the menu.
Can I add Cajun ingredients to my own pizza?
The menu has a Create Your Pizza option, so you can build a pie from the toppings on offer. Ask at the counter which Louisiana ingredients are available as single toppings that day.
Is the cornmeal crust gluten-free?
No gluten-free crust is listed on our menu. There is a Gluten-Free Brownie on the dessert list. If gluten is a concern, ask the staff at 1243 2nd Ave how the kitchen handles it before ordering.
What should I drink with a Cajun pie?
We carry Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke, Pepsi and water. With a spicy pie like The Bayou Beast, a cold Sweet Leaf tea or a Hal’s seltzer is an easy match.
