You come up the stairs at Grove Street, the plaza opens in front of you, and Two Boots at 133 Newark Ave is a short walk away on the pedestrian stretch of Newark Avenue. That’s the whole answer if you’re searching for pizza near Grove Street Jersey City: get off the PATH, head up Newark Ave, and pick between a slice in hand or a pie to carry home.
The rest of this guide is about fitting that stop into your actual evening. We wrote it for one person in particular: the commuter riding the PATH back from Manhattan who is too hungry to cook and too tired to sit through a long dinner. If you’re meeting friends downtown instead, there’s a plan for you too.
Two Boots has been baking Cajun-Italian pies on a cornmeal crust since 1987, when Phil Hartman opened the first shop on Avenue A in the East Village. The Jersey City shop brings that same menu across the river, a short walk from the train.
Key Takeaways
- Two Boots Jersey City sits at 133 Newark Ave, a short walk from the Grove Street PATH entrance along the Newark Ave pedestrian plaza.
- Commuters heading home usually want one of two orders: a slice and garlic knots to eat now, or a whole pie for the apartment.
- Pies travel well to Hamilton Park or a Liberty State Park picnic, as long as you plan the carry and skip the extra bags.
- Groups meeting at Grove Street can split two or three named pies, and bigger crowds can book drop-off catering with 24 to 48 hours’ notice.
Check Out Our Menu!
How to Get Pizza Near Grove Street Jersey City Straight From the PATH
From the Grove Street PATH station, you walk onto the plaza and follow Newark Avenue to number 133, which takes a short walk with no turns worth worrying about. The pedestrian section of Newark Ave is closed to cars, so the last stretch is just you, the storefronts and whoever is out eating on the plaza that night.
The station has more than one way up to the street. If you surface on the side facing the plaza, you’re already pointed the right way. If you come up somewhere else, find Newark Avenue first and the rest is simple.
A few things trip people up. Rush hour moves fast through the station, and the plaza can fill with people walking three abreast. Give yourself a minute to step out of the flow before checking your phone for the order.
The other mistake is timing. Plenty of commuters wait until they’re already on the train to decide what they want, then stand on the sidewalk scrolling. Decide on the ride. If you order a whole pie ahead online, you can walk in, pick it up and keep moving.
For the train itself, the official PATH site from the Port Authority has service updates and maps. We’d check it before you leave the office, especially on weekends when service patterns can change.
Here’s how the walk breaks down, in plain terms:
| Step | What you’ll see | Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Exit Grove Street PATH | The plaza at street level | Step out of the commuter flow before you stop |
| Find Newark Avenue | The car-free pedestrian stretch | Follow the storefronts, not the traffic lights |
| Walk to 133 Newark Ave | Two Boots on the plaza | Pick up an order placed on the train |
| Carry on home | Downtown side streets | Keep the box flat so the toppings stay put |
What Should a PATH Commuter Order on the Way Home?
Order for what happens next: a slice and knots if you’ll eat within ten steps of the door, a whole pie if you’re heading home to a couch and a second person.
We’ll take a position here. For two people going home on a weeknight, one whole pie beats two slices each. You get one box to carry, the leftovers become tomorrow’s lunch, and nobody argues over who got the bigger corner.
Solo commuters are a different story. A single slice, three garlic knots and a Boylan soda will hold you until you get your shoes off.
| Your plan | What to order | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Eating on the walk home | A slice plus Garlic Knots (3) | Fits in one hand, done before your front door |
| Couch dinner for two | One whole named pie | One box, leftovers for lunch |
| Meeting friends on the plaza | Two or three pies to split | Everyone tries something different |
| Hamilton Park hangout | A pie plus Hot Knots | Easy to share on a bench or the grass |
| Liberty State Park picnic | Pies plus a Caesar or House salad | Travels well, feeds a blanket full of people |
| Office party in downtown JC | Drop-off catering | Delivered with 24 to 48 hours’ notice |
If anyone in your crew is vegan, sort that out first. Two Boots makes a long list of vegan pies with Daiya non-dairy cheese, so a mixed group doesn’t have to settle for a plain cheese pie and a side salad.
The Pies Grove Street Regulars Reach For
The pies that work best for a commuter are the ones with big, clear flavors that still taste good after a short walk home in a box. Our menu is long and every pie is named after a pop-culture icon, so here’s a shortlist built for this crowd.
| Pie | What’s on it | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| The Bayou Beast | Spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, mozzarella | The commuter who wants the full Cajun experience |
| Cleopatra Jones | Sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions, mozzarella | Friends who want a crowd-pleaser to split |
| Grandma Bess | Organic San Marzano, garlic, olive oil, basil, Parmigiano, mozzarella on a thin, square Sicilian crust | Anyone who likes a simple, sauce-forward square |
| The Buckminster | Marinara, organic spinach, roasted garlic, parmigiano, provolone, mozzarella | Vegetarians who still want three cheeses |
| The Dude | Ground beef and andouille, tasso ham, cheddar, mozzarella | The hungriest person off the train |
| V for Vegan | Daiya non-dairy cheese on our cornmeal crust | Plant-based riders |
| Mr. Pink | Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella | Chicken fans who want flavor without jalapeños |
At Two Boots Jersey City, The Bayou Beast is the pie that explains the name. Shrimp and crawfish from the Louisiana boot, mozzarella and a crisp crust from the Italian one. It’s marked spicy on the menu, so warn anyone who isn’t ready for jalapeños.
For a gentler pick, Grandma Bess comes on a thin, square Sicilian crust with San Marzano tomatoes and basil. It holds up well in a box and is good cold the next morning, which matters more than people admit.
Want something to dip the crust into? Cajun Ranch and Sweet Red Pepper Pesto are easy wins. Jalapeño Pesto is the spicy dipper if your group likes heat.
Around Grove Street: Hamilton Park, Journal Square and the Rest of Downtown
Grove Street works as a hub for downtown Jersey City, which is why so many plans start at the PATH and end with pizza on Newark Ave. The station connects you to Manhattan in one direction and to Journal Square in the other, and the surrounding blocks are full of reasons to linger.
Hamilton Park. This leafy downtown square sits north of the Grove Street area, within walking distance. Picking up a pie on Newark Ave and carrying it to a bench there is one of the easiest evenings in downtown JC. Bring napkins. If you’ve got kids along, a Pizza Face pie (our small, kid-friendly face pie) goes down well with the under-ten crowd.
Liberty State Park. The big green space on the waterfront, with views across the harbor toward the Statue of Liberty and lower Manhattan. It’s farther than Hamilton Park, so it works better as a planned picnic than a spur-of-the-moment walk. The official Liberty State Park page from NJ State Parks has directions and park information before you head out with a stack of boxes.
Journal Square. If you live up near Journal Square, Grove Street is a quick PATH ride back the other way. Plenty of people stop at Grove Street to eat with friends and then ride home, or carry a pie onto the train for the last leg.
The plaza itself. The pedestrian stretch of Newark Avenue is where downtown JC meets up. It’s a natural landmark for “meet me at Grove Street” plans, and the city’s own Jersey City website is the place to check for street events and closures that might change the scene on a given evening.
Two Boots has been part of this block for a while. Our older guide to pizza near Jersey City covers the shop from a local’s point of view; this one is for anyone whose evening runs through the PATH station.
Can You Carry a Pie From Newark Ave to Liberty State Park?
Yes, a whole pie carries fine to Liberty State Park if you plan the trip, keep the boxes flat and don’t overorder. The trouble starts when people buy for the group they hope shows up instead of the group that’s confirmed.
Our rule for park picnics: count heads, then order one pie fewer than your instinct says, and add a salad and knots instead. Pies stack. Six boxes do not, at least not for one person on foot.
The second thing that goes wrong is wind. The waterfront at Liberty State Park gets breezy, and a lifted box lid is how a slice ends up on the grass. Put a water bottle on top.
And the third is simple hunger. If you’re heading out on an empty stomach, grab a slice for the walk so the pies make it to the blanket intact.
Meeting Friends Downtown or Feeding a Group
A group of four to six meeting at Grove Street should order two or three different pies, not one giant order of the same thing. Splitting named pies is the point of eating at Two Boots; nobody needs four slices of identical pepperoni.
A balanced order for six looks like this: The Bayou Beast for the adventurous, Cleopatra Jones for the reliable crowd-pleaser, and a vegan pie so nobody is left out. Add a round of Garlic Knots or the Chicken Parm sliders on house-made garlic knots if people are coming straight from work.
Bigger groups need a different plan. For an office lunch near the PATH, a birthday in a downtown apartment or a team event, our Jersey City catering does drop-off delivery with packages sized by group. Give us 24 to 48 hours’ notice and the pies arrive ready to open.
One more edge case: picky eaters. Kids and anyone wary of jalapeños can stick with Grandma Bess, The Buckminster or a Create Your Pizza order. Nobody has to pick spicy shrimp to fit in.
Plan Your Stop for Pizza Near Grove Street Jersey City
Decide your order on the train, come up at Grove Street, and walk the plaza to 133 Newark Ave. A slice if you’re eating on the move, a pie if someone’s waiting at home, a few pies if the plan is a park or a crowd. For pizza near Grove Street Jersey City, the Two Boots Jersey City page has the address, ordering link and everything else you need before you leave Manhattan.
FAQs
Is Two Boots close to the Journal Square PATH station?
Two Boots Jersey City is in downtown, by Grove Street, not at Journal Square. If you live near Journal Square, the PATH gets you to Grove Street quickly, and from there the shop is a short walk up Newark Ave.
Can I order ahead and pick up when I get off the PATH?
Yes. Two Boots takes online orders through Toast; start from the Two Boots Jersey City page and make sure the order is going to the Newark Ave shop before you pay. Placing the order while you’re still on the train means less standing around once you arrive.
Does Two Boots Jersey City have vegan pizza?
Yes. The vegan lineup uses Daiya non-dairy cheese and includes V for Vegan, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Mr. Pink and Earth Mother, which comes with marinara and no cheese at all. There’s also a Vegan Calzone.
What drinks can I grab with my pizza?
We stock Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke or Pepsi, and water. Grab one for the walk home, or a few for the park.
Is there something sweet for after the pizza?
Yes, and it’s easy to add to a pickup order. We have a house-baked chocolate chip cookie and a Gluten-Free Brownie, both small enough to stash in a commuter bag for later.
Why is the restaurant called Two Boots?
The name comes from two boot-shaped places on the map: Italy and Louisiana. Phil Hartman opened the first Two Boots on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987, and the menu still mixes Italian pizza with New Orleans Cajun flavors.
