Thanksgiving Dishes, West Village: A Pizza Friendsgiving

Planning Thanksgiving dishes West Village style usually starts with a problem: eleven friends, one walk-up kitchen and an oven that fits a single sheet pan if you take the door off. Here’s the honest answer. You don’t have to cook every dish. Let the guests bring the turkey, the cranberry sauce and the pumpkin pie, and let a few named pies from Two Boots at 101 7th Ave South cover the bread basket, the savory sides, the greens and the plant-based plates.

That’s the Friendsgiving most of the Village actually throws. The NYU student who couldn’t fly home, the designer from the fourth floor, the roommate’s new partner. Chosen family, folding chairs, a radiator clanking along to the playlist. Two Boots doesn’t have a Thanksgiving menu, but our regular lineup fills the gaps on a potluck table neatly.

Key Takeaways

• Treat pizza as a few of the Thanksgiving dishes, not the whole feast: guests bring the turkey and pie, Two Boots covers bread, sides, greens and the vegan lane.
• West Village tables lean veggie, so build around white pies like The Meg, Mel Cooley and Night Tripper, plus Animal Collective as the party-dip pie.
• Bombinis, our savory Cajun hand pies, are a Manhattan-only item and make an easy passed appetizer before the main event.
• Read the potluck sign-up sheet first, then order online for a small group or use the West Village catering page, with 24 to 48 hours of notice, for a bigger crowd.

Check Out Our Menu!

Why a Pizza Table Works for a Village Friendsgiving

West Village apartments are beautiful and small. Plenty of walk-ups off Bleecker and Christopher Streets have kitchens where two people can’t open the fridge and the oven at once. Roasting a bird and keeping three sides warm in there is a logistics puzzle. Most hosts solve it the same way: assign dishes, accept help, and buy a few things ready to eat.

Pizza earns its spot because it arrives sliced, holds up at room temperature and covers diets a single casserole can’t. Our name comes from the two “boots” of Italy and Louisiana, and Cajun and Creole flavors are a real part of Southern holiday cooking. The crisp cornmeal crust even has some of the cornbread-style crunch people want in a stuffing.

It fits the neighborhood, too. Two Boots started in 1987 on Avenue A in the East Village, rooted in the downtown punk, arts and activist scene. The West Village has its own long history of people building families outside the traditional script. A potluck where everyone contributes and the vegan guest gets a real plate feels right for 7th Ave South.

Thanksgiving Dishes West Village Potlucks Can Swap for Pizza

The classic Thanksgiving dinner dishes break down into roles: something warm from the bread basket, a savory “stuffing” slot, a showpiece main, something green, something for the kids and something sweet. The turkey, the gravy, the mashed potatoes and the pies from the bakery can stay with your guests. Here’s how the Two Boots menu slots into the rest.

Thanksgiving role	Two Boots stand-in	Why it works on a Village table
Bread basket / rolls	Garlic Knots (3) or Hot Knots (3, doused in jalapeño pesto, marked Spicy)	Grab-and-go while people are still taking off coats
The stuffing slot	Tony Clifton (wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto)	Earthy and savory, the same flavor family as herb stuffing
The creamy casserole	The Meg (provolone, parmigiano, ricotta, mozzarella, roasted garlic, oregano)	Our “very white pie,” rich in the way mac and cheese is
The dip everyone hovers near	Animal Collective (spinach-artichoke dip, a dash of cayenne, scallions)	The appetizer people mention in the group chat afterward
The greens	Larry Tate (organic spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, white pie) or a Caesar Salad	Something green that people will actually eat
The bright side dish	Mel Cooley (sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, basil pesto, white pie)	Cuts through the heavier plates
The Southern main	Mr. Pink (Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic)	A Louisiana note for guests who skip turkey
Passed appetizer	Bombinis (savory Cajun hand pies)	Handheld, no plate needed in a standing-room apartment
The gravy boat	Dippers: Sweet Red Pepper Pesto, Basil Pesto, Marinara, Cajun Ranch	Everyone gets to sauce their own
Dessert backup	House-baked chocolate chip cookies or the Gluten-Free Brownie	Covers the gap if the pie shows up late

You don’t need every row. Most Village hosts we’d talk to pick three or four roles and leave the rest to the group.

The White Pie and Veggie Lane: Built for a Village Crowd

Downtown Friendsgivings skew vegetarian. Somebody gave up meat in college, somebody is “mostly plant-based,” and somebody just doesn’t trust the turkey. Luckily, our white and veggie pies are some of the most holiday-feeling items on the menu.

The Meg goes at the center. It’s our very white pie, no tomato sauce, lots of cheese, and it plays the bubbly casserole without anyone fighting the oven for it.

Mel Cooley brings color to a table full of beige foods (we love beige foods). Sun-dried tomatoes and roasted peppers make it the cranberry sauce of the pizza world, bright and a little tart.

Night Tripper is for the guest who carries hot sauce in their bag: sun-dried tomatoes, roasted garlic and jalapeño pesto on a white pie, marked Spicy on the menu. Flag it on the table.

Animal Collective is the conversation starter. If your Friendsgiving playlist runs to indie records, the name will land.

Round it out with The Buckminster (marinara on top over organic spinach and roasted garlic) and Grandma Bess, whose thin square Sicilian slices stack neatly on a crowded counter.

The Vegan Lane and the Kids’ Table

Every Village Friendsgiving has a guest who has eaten a lot of plain side salads at holiday dinners. Give them a real plate. Our vegan pies use Daiya non-dairy cheese.

• V for Vegan: artichokes, red onions and wild mushrooms with a criss-cross of sweet red pepper and basil pestos.
• Earth Mother: organic spinach, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, wild mushrooms, red onion and marinara, no cheese at all.
• Vegan Tony Clifton and Vegan Larry Tate: the stuffing slot and the greens, made dairy-free.
• Super Vegan, Vegan Mr. Pink, Vegan Cleo and The VCBGB for guests who want something hearty.
• Vegan Calzone: a good one to set aside for a guest arriving late from a shift.

For kids at the table, Pizza Face is a small, kid-friendly face pie, and a cheese pizza through Create Your Pizza keeps picky eaters happy. Put a folded label card by each pie. In a crowded apartment, that saves a lot of “is this one vegan?” questions.

For more on the plant-based side of our 7th Ave South shop, our earlier post on vegan pizza near you in the West Village goes deeper.

How Much to Order for a West Village Friendsgiving

Pizza is there to fill gaps, so you’ll usually need less than you think if guests are bringing a turkey and sides. These are rough starting points, not rules. Appetites vary, and late arrivals always want a slice.

Group	Pies	Knots and extras	Vegan cover
4 to 6 (roommates and a couple of strays)	2 pies, one white and one veggie	1 order of Garlic Knots, a few Bombinis	Half the table vegan? Make one pie V for Vegan
7 to 10 (classic walk-up Friendsgiving)	3 to 4 pies across white, veggie and one Creole pick	2 orders of knots, Bombinis, a Caesar Salad	At least one full vegan pie
11 to 15 (the chosen-family blowout)	5 to 6 pies, plus Grandma Bess squares	Knots, sliders, two salads, a spread of dippers	Two vegan pies and a Vegan Calzone
16+ or an office Friendsgiving	Use catering	Mix pies, sliders, salads and dippers by headcount	Ask for veg and vegan options in the package

Two small-space tips: put the Bombinis and knots out as people arrive and hold the pies until the turkey is carved, and leave a couple of slices unclaimed. Cold pizza the next morning is a tradition of its own.

A Pre-Dinner Walk: Washington Square, Bleecker and Christopher Street

Some of the best Village Friendsgivings start outside. A loop through the neighborhood before dinner gets everyone hungry and out of the host’s tiny kitchen while the turkey rests.

Start at Washington Square Park, the heart of the NYU end of the Village. The arch and the fountain make it the natural meeting spot for out-of-town friends who don’t know which buzzer to press yet. From there, wander west along Bleecker Street, past the shop windows and the record-hunting crowd, and cut up Christopher Street.

Christopher Street brings you straight to Sheridan Square and our shop at 101 7th Ave South, a familiar landmark for anyone who has ever grabbed a slice on the walk home.

This is a neighborhood of creatives, students and longtime residents, many of whom built their holiday traditions around friends rather than suburban family dinners. It treats dinner as the start of the night, not the end of it, which is exactly the energy a good Friendsgiving needs.

Ordering Ahead and Catering for Thanksgiving Week

Thanksgiving week is busy for everyone, so plan a little.

• Small Friendsgiving: use the Order Online button on our West Village location page. Ordering runs through Toast.
• Bigger group: use our West Village catering page. Catering is drop-off delivery with packages by group size and vegetarian and vegan options, and it needs 24 to 48 hours of notice. Good for an office Friendsgiving or an NYU club dinner before the break.
• Host gift: Two Boots gift cards are sold through Toast, and they’re easier to carry up a fifth-floor walk-up than a casserole dish.

For the full knot rundown, see our older guide to garlic knots in the West Village.

Pairing Pizza With What Your Guests Bring

Once the sign-up sheet comes back, look at the gaps and order around them.

• Someone’s roasting a turkey? Go veggie and white: The Meg, Mel Cooley, Larry Tate.
• Three people signed up for dessert? It happens every year. Lean savory with Tony Clifton and Garlic Knots.
• No main at all? It’s a Friendsgiving, it’s allowed. Make Mr. Pink or The Bayou Beast (marked Spicy) the centerpiece.
• Half the guests are vegan? Lead with V for Vegan and Earth Mother.

Conclusion

The easiest Thanksgiving dishes West Village hosts can serve are the ones they don’t have to cook in a closet-sized kitchen. Let your chosen family bring the turkey and the pie, and let Two Boots cover the bread basket, the savory sides, the greens and the vegan lane. Build around The Meg, Mel Cooley and Animal Collective, add a few Bombinis, and order ahead.

Find directions, the Order Online button and more on our West Village location page, then come find us at 101 7th Ave South at Sheridan Square on your way back from the park.

FAQs