Yes, you can get proper vegan pizza in Park Slope without making the rest of the house suffer through a compromise. Two Boots Park Slope at 284 5th Ave makes eight vegan pies, a Vegan Calzone, four vegan dippers and a vegan House Salad. Most of it uses Daiya non-dairy cheese, and one pie skips cheese entirely.

This guide is for one household in particular. The one on a brownstone block off 5th Ave where one person is vegan (a partner, a teenager who went plant-based last spring, a seven-year-old who decided after a farm trip) and everyone else would happily eat sausage on everything. You’re ordering for a Prospect Park afternoon or a Tuesday night on the couch, and you want the vegan in the family to get dinner, not a consolation prize.

So this isn’t another list of vegan pies. It’s the full order: what’s vegan on our menu beyond the pizza, what isn’t, and how to split it so nobody’s picking at a side salad.

Key Takeaways

  • Two Boots Park Slope on 5th Ave has eight vegan pies, a Vegan Calzone, four vegan dippers and a vegan House Salad on the menu.
  • Garlic Knots and the parm sliders are not vegan, and Hot Knots aren’t labeled vegan, so ask before you order them.
  • For a household of four with one vegan, order one whole vegan pie plus one regular pie, not a single vegan slice.
  • Vegan slice options change, so ask at the counter; a whole pie is the sure thing.

Check Out Our Menu!

Vegan Pizza Park Slope Lineup: Which Pie Should You Order?

Our vegan pizza lineup in Park Slope runs to eight pies, and the right one depends on whether your vegan wants cheese, protein or a pile of vegetables. Seven of them use Daiya non-dairy cheese. The Earth Mother goes without, and leans on marinara and roasted vegetables instead.

Two of the pies, the Super Vegan and the Vegan Larry Tate, add vegan ricotta. And the plant-based proteins (vegan chicken and vegan sausage) come from Be-Hive, according to our FAQ.

Pie What’s on it Pick it if…
V for Vegan Artichokes, red onions, wild mushrooms, a criss-cross of sweet red pepper pesto and basil pesto, Daiya It’s their first Two Boots vegan pie and you want the flagship
Earth Mother Organic spinach, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, wild mushrooms, red onion, marinara, no cheese Your vegan doesn’t like non-dairy cheese at all
The VCBGB Vegan chicken, broccoli, garlic, basil pesto, Daiya The family orders The CBGB and the vegan wants the same pie
Vegan Cleo Vegan sausage, roasted peppers, red onion, Daiya You want something that looks just like the Cleopatra Jones next to it
Super Vegan Broccoli, artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil pesto, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya, vegan ricotta They want the most loaded pie on the vegan side
Vegan Tony Clifton Wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto, Daiya Mushroom people, plain and simple
Vegan Larry Tate Organic spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, vegan ricotta, Daiya The vegan kid who wants a white-ish pie
Vegan Mr. Pink Vegan chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, Daiya A teenager who wants protein and doesn’t want vegetables

Our pick for a first order is the Vegan Cleo.

It’s the closest thing on the menu to a classic sausage-and-peppers pie, and next to a regular Cleopatra Jones in the same box it makes the point that vegan dinner can be the same dinner.

The Earth Mother is the other one worth knowing. It comes in 10″, 14″ and 18″ on the menu, which makes it easy to size up or down for one eater. Small appetite, small pie.

Every vegan pie bakes on the same cornmeal crust as every other pie we make. That crust goes back to the first Two Boots, which Phil Hartman opened on Avenue A in the East Village in 1987, with the name borrowed from the two boot-shaped places that shaped the menu: Italy and Louisiana.

If you want the full rundown of each pie and its pop-culture backstory, our earlier guide to vegan pizza near me in Park Slope covers them one by one.

What Else on the Menu Is Vegan, and What Isn’t?

Beyond the pies, the items labeled vegan on our menu are the Vegan Calzone, four dippers (Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and Basil Pesto) and the House Salad. That’s enough to build a full plant-based order with a side and something to dunk crusts into.

This is the part most “vegan pizza in Brooklyn” lists skip. They tell you a shop has a vegan pie and stop there. Then somebody orders knots for the table and the vegan in your house is left staring at them.

Item Vegan? Note
Vegan Calzone Yes Daiya and vegan ricotta, with a side of marinara
Marinara dipper Yes The default for crusts
Basil Pesto dipper Yes Labeled vegan on the menu
Sweet Red Pepper Pesto dipper Yes Same pesto that’s on the V for Vegan
Jalapeño Pesto dipper Yes Also marked spicy
House Salad Yes Organic mixed greens, chickpeas, red onion, shredded carrot
Garlic Knots No Made with butter and Parmigiano
Hot Knots Ask Not labeled vegan on the menu, so check at the counter
Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm, Eggplant Parm sliders No All have mozzarella
Gluten-Free Brownie, chocolate chip cookie Not labeled vegan Don’t assume either way; ask

The Eggplant Parm slider is the one that catches people out. It sounds like the vegetarian-friendly pick, and it is vegetarian, but it comes with mozzarella. Order it for the omnivores and keep it off the vegan’s plate.

The Vegan Calzone is the sleeper. A kid who won’t eat toppings will often eat a folded pocket of Daiya and vegan ricotta, and it dunks well in the marinara it comes with.

Drinks are the easy part. Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas and Hal’s seltzer are all in the fridge. Kids tend to go straight for the Boylan.

Vegan Slice or Whole Pie for a Mixed Household?

For a household of four with one vegan, order a whole vegan pie, not one vegan slice. That’s our position and we’ll defend it.

Here’s why. We do sell pizza by the slice, but which vegan pies are out by the slice changes, so a vegan slice isn’t something you can count on when you walk in. A whole pie is the order that’s guaranteed. It also means your vegan gets seconds, and gets to share, which is the whole point of eating together.

And leftover vegan pizza is a gift.

Cold Vegan Cleo the next morning is a better breakfast than whatever’s in the fridge.

Your household What to order Why
2 adults, 1 vegan One vegan pie plus one regular pie Each person gets their pie, and the vegan pie doubles as lunch tomorrow
2 adults, 2 kids, 1 vegan kid Vegan Calzone for the kid, one large regular pie, a marinara dipper Kids rarely finish a whole pie; a calzone feels like their own thing
4 adults, 1 vegan One vegan pie plus two regular pies (Grandma Bess and Cleopatra Jones work) The vegan pie usually gets raided, so it’s better to have one too many slices than too few
Half the table is vegan Two vegan pies, one regular, House Salad for the table Nobody has to ration

A tip from the counter: if the family’s regular order is The CBGB or Mr. Pink, get the vegan version too (The VCBGB or Vegan Mr. Pink). Same flavor profile, two boxes, nobody feels like they’re eating “the other pizza.”

Plant-Based Pizza in Park Slope, From 5th Ave to the Park

Two Boots Park Slope sits at 284 5th Ave, which puts plant-based pizza in Park Slope a short walk from almost everywhere a brownstone family spends a weekend. Up the hill is Prospect Park. North along 5th Ave and Flatbush is Barclays Center. Home is somewhere in between.

This neighborhood is full of mixed households. A vegan parent and two omnivore kids. A vegan teenager in a family of meat-eaters. Grandparents visiting from out of town who’ve never heard of Daiya. 5th Ave is where all of them end up for dinner.

The Prospect Park afternoon

The move we’d recommend: pick up a whole vegan pie and a regular pie, walk up the hill past the brownstone side streets, and eat on the Long Meadow. Pizza travels fine for a short walk, and a box on a blanket beats a picnic someone spent all morning assembling.

Bring napkins. Bring the marinara dipper. Bring a bag for the boxes, because the park staff have enough to deal with on a sunny Saturday.

If you’re coming from the Grand Army Plaza end, especially after the Saturday greenmarket, you’re heading downhill toward 5th Ave on the way back. That’s a good time to pick up dinner for later.

The weeknight at home

Not every vegan pizza night needs a picnic. Plenty of Park Slope households order in on a school night because nobody has the energy to cook two dinners. One vegan pie and one regular pie means one dinner, two boxes, zero arguments about whose turn it is.

Before a Nets game or a show

For a family heading up 5th Ave to Barclays Center, eat first and then walk. The vegan in your group gets a full Vegan Cleo or V for Vegan at a table, which is a lot better than hunting for something plant-based near the arena doors.

Catering a Plant-Based Crowd in Park Slope

Our Park Slope catering does drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, and the packages are built around group size, with vegetarian and vegan options included. It’s a good fit for a birthday party where half the kids’ parents have sent dietary notes, or a block-association meeting in somebody’s parlor floor.

For a crowd, plan about one vegan pie for every three or four vegan guests, then add one more. Non-vegans eat from the vegan side too, especially when it’s the Super Vegan, and the vegans are the ones who lose out if you cut it fine. Ask about the vegan options when you book so the order is set before the party starts.

See the Two Boots Park Slope catering page for packages and how to book.

Order Vegan Pizza in Park Slope This Week

The one thing to remember: order the vegan pie whole, and ask at the counter about vegan slices and anything not labeled. Every November, for World Vegan Month, Two Boots teams up with a local vegan food vendor on a featured vegan pie of the month, so ask whether it’s on when you come in.

So the next time someone in your house types “vegan pizza Park Slope” into a phone, skip the scrolling. Start with the Vegan Cleo, add a House Salad, and head to Two Boots Park Slope at 284 5th Ave.

FAQs

Is Daiya cheese free of dairy?

Daiya is a non-dairy cheese, which is why we use it on our vegan pies. If anyone in your household has a dairy allergy rather than a dietary choice, tell the staff when you order so they know what you need, because a pizza shop handles real mozzarella all day. We can tell you what’s on each pie; we can’t promise a dairy-free kitchen.

Can I make any pie on the menu vegan?

The safest route is to order one of the eight vegan pies as listed, since those are the combinations we built to work with Daiya and vegan ricotta. If you want to build something else, Create Your Pizza lets you choose your toppings, and staff can tell you which ones are plant-based.

What is vegan ricotta, and which pies have it?

Vegan ricotta is a dairy-free take on the soft, spoonable cheese, and it shows up on the Super Vegan, the Vegan Larry Tate and the Vegan Calzone. It adds creamy dollops that melt into the pie in a way Daiya alone doesn’t. It’s also why the Super Vegan eats like the heaviest pie on the vegan side.

Do the vegan pies taste like the regular versions?

They’re close cousins, not clones. The Vegan Cleo, The VCBGB, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink follow the same topping ideas as Cleopatra Jones, The CBGB, Tony Clifton, Larry Tate and Mr. Pink, with plant-based swaps for the cheese and meat, so a mixed household can order matching pies side by side.

Is there a kids’ pie that works for a vegan child?

The Pizza Face, our small kid-friendly face pie, isn’t on the vegan list, so don’t count on it for a vegan kid. The Vegan Calzone and the Vegan Larry Tate tend to go down well with younger eaters, and a marinara dipper makes most things more appealing to a six-year-old.

Is one vegan pie enough for two people?

For two adults sharing, one vegan pie with a House Salad is usually a full dinner. If both of you are hungry after an afternoon walking the park, size up or add a Vegan Calzone, and the leftovers will keep.