The Upper West Side has a reputation. Prewar doorman buildings, opera subscriptions, brunch lines on Columbus Avenue. So when people search for affordable restaurants Upper West Side neighbors actually use, they usually land on giant listicles that name twenty places and leave you to do the math. We’d like to offer something more useful: a playbook.

Here’s our honest, biased answer. A neighborhood slice-and-share pizza shop is one of the most wallet-friendly ways to eat out on the Upper West Side, and Two Boots at 70 W. 71st St, half a block off Columbus Avenue and a short stroll from Central Park West, is built for exactly that. You can grab a single slice on the way to Lincoln Center, split one big pie across a table of friends, or stretch a family order with knots and salads. The savings don’t come from a gimmick. They come from how you order.

Below: when to go by the slice and when to commit to a whole pie, which sides do the most work, how to plan a nearly free afternoon in the neighborhood around a pizza stop, and how offices and parties keep group meals sensible.

Key Takeaways

  • A slice-and-share pizza shop is one of the easiest ways to eat out affordably on the Upper West Side, because you order exactly as much as the table needs.
  • Whole pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes for many items, so groups can split one larger pie instead of ordering separate plates.
  • Garlic Knots, sliders on house-made knots, calzones, salads and dippers stretch an order without forcing a second pie.
  • For offices, schools and parties, our Upper West Side catering page handles drop-off group orders with 24 to 48 hours of notice.

Check Out Our Menu!

Why a Slice Shop Belongs on Any List of Affordable Restaurants Upper West Side Locals Use

Most sit-down dinners lock you in. Everyone orders their own entree, the table adds a round of appetizers nobody really needed, and the meal grows a life of its own. A pizza shop flips that. Food lands in the middle of the table, people take what they want, and you can stop ordering the moment everyone’s full.

That flexibility is the real value lever. A solo diner can walk in, order one slice and be back on the sidewalk in minutes. Two people can share a small pie and a side of knots. Six roommates can split an 18″ pie and a calzone and still have leftovers for tomorrow. Nobody is paying for food they didn’t want.

Then there’s the menu itself. Two Boots has been mixing the two “boots” of the map, Italy and Louisiana, since 1987, when Phil Hartman opened the first shop on Avenue A in the East Village. That means a crisp cornmeal crust, pies named after pop-culture icons, and Cajun-Italian combinations like crawfish and andouille sitting next to classic basil pesto and Parmigiano.

Slice, Small Pie or Big Pie? Sizing the Order to the Table

The single biggest way to spend smart at a pizza shop is to match the format to the group. Here’s how we’d think about it, no calculator required.

Who’s eating What to order Why it works
Just you, between errands A slice or two No commitment, in and out, and you can try a different pie next time
Two people on a casual date A 10″ pie plus Garlic Knots One pie to share and a side to dunk, without ordering two of everything
Three or four friends A 14″ pie plus a salad One shared pie covers the group, the salad adds something green
Five to eight roommates or teammates An 18″ pie, a second pie and sliders Splitting larger pies is where sharing really pays off
Mixed vegan and non-vegan group One Daiya vegan pie plus one meat or veggie pie Everyone eats from one order instead of splitting up
Kids in the group Pizza Face (small only) plus a grown-up pie Little eaters get their own mini pie, adults get flavor

A few notes on getting it right:

Slices are for testing. Try a new pie by the slice before committing a whole one to the table.

Bigger pies shine when you split. Whole pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes for many items on our menu. When a group shares one larger pie instead of each person buying their own food, the math tends to work in your favor. We won’t quote numbers here; the menu has everything current.

Create Your Pizza keeps it simple. It starts with cheese and you add only what you want. If your group only agrees on two toppings, order exactly that and skip the rest.

Shareables That Stretch an Order (Without a Second Pie)

Sometimes the group is hungrier than one pie but not quite hungry enough for two. That’s what the sides are for. Our menu has a strong bench of shareable extras, and they’re the quiet heroes of an affordable night out.

Shareable What it is Use it for
Garlic Knots (3) or Hot Knots (3) Knots in butter, garlic and Parmigiano, or doused in jalapeño pesto The universal table starter
Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm or Eggplant Parm sliders Served on house-made garlic knots; the Meatball Parm uses andouille meatballs Filling add-on for big appetites
Classic Calzone or Vegan Calzone A folded, portable meal of its own Rounding out a group order
Caesar or House Salad The House Salad is vegan Adds greens and stretches a pie
Bombinis (Small or Large) Savory Cajun hand pies, Manhattan locations only A handheld option for walking to the park
Dippers Blue Cheese, Cajun Ranch, Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto, Basil Pesto Turning crusts into a second course

Dippers are the secret weapon. Lots of people leave crusts behind. Put out a Basil Pesto or Cajun Ranch dipper and suddenly the crusts disappear, which means you get more meal out of the same pie.

Bombinis are an Upper West Side perk. These savory Cajun hand pies are only on the menu at our Manhattan shops, which includes West 71st.

We wrote a whole earlier piece about our garlic knots on the Upper West Side if you want the deep dive on knot strategy.

Affordable Restaurants Upper West Side

A Low-Cost Upper West Side Day, With Pizza in the Middle

Here’s the thing about eating affordably on the Upper West Side: the neighborhood itself is the main course. Some of the city’s great experiences sit within walking distance of 70 W. 71st St, and the parks and plazas are free to enjoy. Pair a pizza order with any of these and you’ve got a full day out.

Central Park, a block and a half east. Walk to Central Park West and cross into the park near West 72nd Street. Strawberry Fields is right there, and from there you can wander toward Bethesda Terrace, the Lake and the Sheep Meadow lawn. The Central Park Conservancy has maps, events and seasonal guides. A to-go pie, a couple of Garlic Knots and a blanket on the grass is a classic Upper West Side picnic.

Riverside Park, a walk west. Head toward the Hudson and you’ll hit Riverside Park, run by NYC Parks, with river views, long paths and benches perfect for watching the sunset over New Jersey. It’s a bit of a walk, so this is where portable Bombinis or calzones earn their keep.

Lincoln Center, just south. The plaza and the fountain are open to stroll, and the campus is one of the neighborhood’s great people-watching spots.

The Natural History Museum, a few blocks north. The museum sits along Central Park West in the high 70s. Check the museum’s own site for its admission options before you go.

The Beacon Theatre on Broadway. Heading to a show at the Beacon, a few minutes’ walk from us? Eat at a pizza shop first, skip the rushed pre-theater menu and still make your seat.

Upper West Side outing Pair it with Why it works
Picnic at Strawberry Fields or Sheep Meadow A 14″ pie and Garlic Knots to go Shareable, no utensils, travels a block and a half
Sunset walk in Riverside Park Bombinis and a chocolate chip cookie Handheld and Manhattan-only
Pre-show at the Beacon Theatre A slice and a Spindrift Quick, light, done before doors
Evening on the Lincoln Center plaza Sliders to share Filling but easy to finish fast
Museum visit on Central Park West A Pizza Face and a grown-up pie Tired kids and hungry adults, one order

Office Lunches, Rehearsals and Parties: Feeding a Group Sensibly

The Upper West Side runs on groups: office teams near Columbus Circle, rehearsal casts around Lincoln Center, school committees, building parties, study groups. Feeding twenty people is where costs usually spiral, mainly because individual orders add up and nobody wants to coordinate.

Catering keeps that under control. Start with our Upper West Side catering page. Catering is drop-off delivery, it needs 24 to 48 hours of notice, and packages are organized by group size, so you’re not guessing how many pies to order. Vegetarian and vegan options are part of the picture, which matters when you don’t know every guest’s diet.

A sensible group-order formula:

  1. Anchor with crowd-pleasers. A cheese pie and a classic like Cleopatra Jones (sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions) cover most of the room.
  2. Add one vegetable pie. Larry Tate or The Buckminster gives the veggie eaters something real.
  3. Include one vegan pie. V for Vegan or Earth Mother means the plant-based crowd isn’t stuck with salad.
  4. Use knots and sliders as filler. They stretch the spread more gracefully than another pie.
  5. Finish small. House-baked chocolate chip cookies and Gluten-Free Brownies are an easy dessert without a cake.

Mixed Tables: Vegan, Meat Lovers and Kids in One Order

One of the hidden costs of eating out with a group is splitting up. The vegan friend wants one place, the meat lover wants another, the kids want something plain, and suddenly you’re paying for two separate dinners. A menu that covers everyone keeps the group, and the bill, in one place.

For the vegans. Our vegan lineup is a full section, built on Daiya non-dairy cheese: V for Vegan, Earth Mother (marinara, no cheese), The VCBGB, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink. Add the Vegan Calzone and the vegan House Salad and a plant-based eater has a whole meal.

For the meat lovers. The Dude is a Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie with ground beef, andouille, tasso ham, cheddar and mozzarella. Mr. Pink brings Creole chicken with plum tomatoes and garlic.

For the kids. Pizza Face is our kid-friendly face pie, small size only. Create Your Pizza starts from cheese, so a picky eater can keep it plain. The Meg, a very white pie with four cheeses and roasted garlic, works for kids who refuse red sauce.

Two Boots also runs a loyalty program and sells gift cards through Toast. Ask at the counter or check our site for how they work.

Conclusion

Eating well on the Upper West Side doesn’t require a reservation, a prix fixe or a second mortgage on your rent-stabilized apartment. It requires a smart order: slices when you’re solo, a shared pie when you’re with friends, knots and dippers to stretch it, and catering when the group gets big.

Find us at 70 W. 71st St, between Columbus Avenue and Central Park West, and start your order from our Upper West Side location page.

FAQs

Is Two Boots an affordable restaurant on the Upper West Side?

We’re a neighborhood pizza shop, and that format makes it easy to control what you spend. You can order a single slice, share a whole pie across a group, or add shareable sides like Garlic Knots instead of ordering separate entrees. Current menu items and sizes are listed on our menu page.

What’s the most wallet-friendly way to order for a group?

Split larger pies. Whole pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes for many items, and sharing one or two bigger pies across a table usually goes further than individual meals. Add Garlic Knots, sliders or a salad to stretch the order instead of jumping to another pie.

Do you have vegan options so a mixed group can eat together?

Yes. Our vegan pies use Daiya non-dairy cheese and include V for Vegan, Earth Mother, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan and more. There’s also a Vegan Calzone and a vegan House Salad, so vegans and non-vegans can share one order.

What are Bombinis, and can I get them on the Upper West Side?

Bombinis are savory Cajun hand pies, available in Small and Large. They’re only on the menu at our Manhattan locations, and the Upper West Side shop at 70 W. 71st St is one of them. They’re easy to carry to Central Park or Riverside Park.

Can I order catering for an office or party near Lincoln Center?

Yes. Our Upper West Side catering page offers drop-off delivery with packages organized by group size, including vegetarian and vegan options. Catering needs 24 to 48 hours of notice, so place your order once your date is set.

Do you have a loyalty program or gift cards?

Yes. Two Boots offers a loyalty program and gift cards through Toast. Ask our team at the counter or check our website for details on how they work.