The West Village is famous for its tiny tasting-menu rooms, candlelit wine bars and brunch lines that wrap around the block. It is less famous for being easy on the wallet. But if you are searching for affordable restaurants West Village locals actually use on a regular Tuesday, the answer is often hiding in plain sight: a neighborhood slice shop. Two Boots at 101 7th Ave S, right on Sheridan Square, lets you order exactly as much as you want, one slice or a whole pie, and share the rest.

That is the whole trick. No second round of small plates you did not need: just pizza by the slice or by the pie, split with friends, stretched with garlic knots and dippers, and walked off down Bleecker Street.

Below: sizing an order for one or ten, the shareables that do the most work, feeding a mixed table, and pairing a pie with the free stuff the Village does so well.

Key Takeaways

  • A slice-and-share pizza shop is one of the most wallet-friendly ways to eat out in the West Village, because you control exactly how much you order.
  • Whole pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes for many menu items, so a group can split one bigger pie instead of ordering separate plates.
  • Garlic Knots, sliders, calzones, salads, Bombinis and dippers stretch a pie into a full meal for the table.
  • For office lunches, NYU club meetings and parties, West Village catering is drop-off with 24 to 48 hours’ notice and packages by group size.

Check Out Our Menu!

Why a Slice Shop Belongs on Any List of Affordable Restaurants West Village Locals Trust

Most round-ups of affordable restaurants in the West Village are long lists of places and price tags. Here instead is why a slice shop keeps showing up in real routines around Sheridan Square.

You set the portion. A single slice is a real meal option, not a sad appetizer. Hungry? Get two. Sharing with a friend? Order a whole pie and split it. Nobody is upselling you to a third course.

Sharing is built in. Pizza is the original group plate. A big pie cut into slices divides cleanly, and the leftovers travel home in the box for tomorrow’s lunch.

Variety without waste. Our menu blends Italy and Louisiana, so one table can mix a classic Grandma Bess, a Cajun Bayou Beast and a vegan V for Vegan. You do not need three different restaurants to keep three different eaters happy.

It fits the neighborhood’s rhythm. You grab a slice on 7th Avenue South, eat it on a bench, and keep going. The meal works around your plans instead of taking over your evening.

Two Boots has been feeding downtown since 1987, when it opened on Avenue A in the East Village, so easy, unfussy eating is kind of the point.

Slice, Whole Pie or Size Up: Ordering by Group Size

The single most useful move for eating well for less is matching your order to your crowd. Here is the cheat sheet we would give a friend standing at our counter on 7th Ave South. It is about quantity and strategy, not prices.

Who’s eating Smart order Why it works
Just you, between classes or errands One or two slices Order only what you will eat, then keep moving
Two people on a casual date A 10″ whole pie plus Garlic Knots (3) Small enough to finish, and you each get the crust
Three or four roommates A 14″ pie plus one side, or two different slices each Covers a range of tastes without over-ordering
Five or six friends after the park An 18″ pie plus sliders and a salad One big shared pie does the heavy lifting
A study group or club meeting Two 18″ pies, one classic and one vegan, plus knots Everyone eats from the same order
Picky kid tagging along Pizza Face (small only) A kid-sized pie, so nobody pays for food that comes home untouched

A few practical notes:

  • Create Your Pizza starts with a cheese pizza and lets you add only the toppings you actually want.
  • Slices are the flexible option when a group cannot agree; a whole pie is usually the more efficient split when it can.
  • Leftovers are a feature. A cold slice the next morning is a time-honored breakfast in any dorm near NYU.

If slices are your main move, our older guide to pizza by the slice in the West Village walks through the counter in more detail.

Shareables That Stretch an Order

A pie is the anchor. Shareables turn it into a proper meal: instead of a pie per person, add one or two of these and let the table graze.

Shareable What it is When it helps
Garlic Knots (3) House-made knots, the classic side A starter while you wait for the pie
Hot Knots (3) Knots doused in jalapeño pesto, marked spicy on the menu For the heat-seeker in the group
Chicken Parm slider Chicken parm on a house-made garlic knot Turns a slice into a two-part meal
Meatball Parm slider Andouille meatballs on a garlic knot A Cajun twist for meat lovers
Eggplant Parm slider Eggplant parm on a garlic knot Vegetarian and filling
Classic Calzone A folded, stuffed pizza One more hearty plate for a bigger table
Vegan Calzone The plant-based version Covers the vegan friend without a separate trip
Caesar or House Salad Greens to balance the table (the House is vegan) Makes a shared pie feel like dinner
Bombinis (Small or Large) Savory Cajun hand pies, Manhattan locations only Handheld, easy to share, easy to carry

Dippers turn crusts into a course. This is the move people underrate. Order a couple of dippers (Blue Cheese, Cajun Ranch, Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto or Basil Pesto) and suddenly the crust ends are not leftovers, they are round two. The Jalapeño Pesto is the one marked spicy; the Sweet Red Pepper Pesto and Basil Pesto are gentler.

Bombinis are a Village perk. These savory Cajun hand pies are only served at our Manhattan shops, and they round out a slice order when you want something different but not another whole pie.

Sweet finish. Split a house-baked chocolate chip cookie or a Gluten-Free Brownie.

For drinks, there are Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke and Pepsi, and water.

Affordable Restaurants West Village

A Wallet-Friendly West Village Day, Pie Included

This is the part the listicles miss. The West Village is full of things that cost nothing, and our shop, where 7th Avenue South meets Christopher Street by the 1 train, is an easy start or finish for a day on foot.

Washington Square Park. A few blocks east, Washington Square Park is the neighborhood’s living room: the arch, the fountain, chess players, street musicians and a steady stream of NYU students between classes. Grab a slice and a seltzer and claim a bench. People-watching here is free and endlessly entertaining.

Christopher Street to the river. Walk west down Christopher Street and you hit the Hudson River Park waterfront, with piers, lawns and some of the city’s prettiest sunsets. A boxed pie and a few friends on the grass is about as good a dinner plan as the Village offers.

Bleecker Street browsing. Bleecker is made for slow wandering and window shopping. A Bombini is the right size for eating while you walk.

Free or low-cost Village plan What to grab first Why it pairs well
Bench time in Washington Square Park A slice of Grandma Bess and a Sweet Leaf tea Square slices are tidy to eat outdoors
Sunset walk along the Hudson A 14″ pie to split and a side of Garlic Knots Easy to carry, easy to share on the grass
Bleecker Street wander A Small Bombini per person Handheld food for a group on the move
NYU study break Slices plus a shared Eggplant Parm slider Quick, filling and back to the library
Weekend late night out on Christopher Street A slice of The Dude or Mr. Pink A real meal before heading home
Rainy night in a Village apartment An 18″ Create Your Pizza for the whole flat Everyone adds a topping, one pickup feeds the room

About that late-night line: our West Village shop stays open late on weekends, which is a big reason it has become a regular stop after a night out around Christopher Street and 7th Avenue South. Check the West Village location page for current hours before you go.

Groups, Offices and Parties: Catering That Respects the Spreadsheet

Eventually someone has to feed a crowd: the office lunch, the NYU club kickoff, the birthday in a walk-up apartment. This is where ordering smart pays off most.

Start with our West Village catering page. Catering is drop-off delivery, needs 24 to 48 hours’ notice, and the packages are organized by group size, so you are not guessing how much to order. There are vegetarian and vegan options built in.

A simple formula that keeps a group order efficient:

  1. Lead with crowd-pleasers. Cheese pies through Create Your Pizza, plus a Grandma Bess, cover most guests.
  2. Add one bold pie. Cleopatra Jones (sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions) or The Dude (a Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie) gives the table something to talk about.
  3. Add one vegan pie. V for Vegan or Vegan Larry Tate, so the plant-based guests are fed from the same order.
  4. Use shareables as filler. Garlic Knots, sliders and a big House or Caesar Salad stretch the pies further than ordering another pie would.
  5. Finish small. A tray of house-baked chocolate chip cookies goes further than individual desserts.

Mixed Tables: Vegan, Meat-Lover and Kid in One Order

One quiet way groups overspend is splitting up: the vegan friend goes one place, the meat-eaters another. At Two Boots, one order covers everyone.

For the vegans. Our vegan pies use Daiya non-dairy cheese. V for Vegan, Earth Mother (marinara, no cheese), The VCBGB, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink are all on the menu, plus the Vegan Calzone and the vegan House Salad. Several are vegan versions of pies the rest of the table might order, so a group can get the same pie two ways.

For the meat-lovers. The Bayou Beast (spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños), Super Newman (capicola, sopressata, sweet Italian sausage, ricotta), Big Maybelle (Creole chicken, Zoe’s pepperoni, fresh garlic) and The CBGB (chicken, broccoli, garlic, basil pesto) bring the Louisiana side of the menu. The Bayou Beast is marked spicy on the menu, so warn your friends.

For the kids. Pizza Face, a kid-friendly face pie, comes in small only, which keeps a little one’s order small too.

Put it together and a table of six with three different diets eats from one counter, one bag or one catering drop.

Conclusion

Eating well in the West Village does not have to mean a reservation and a big bill. The smart play is simple: order by the slice when it is just you, size up to a whole pie when there is a group, stretch it with knots, sliders, Bombinis and dippers, and pair it with the parks, streets and waterfront the neighborhood gives away for free.

Find us at 101 7th Ave S on Sheridan Square, a short walk from Washington Square Park and Christopher Street. Start your order from our West Village location page with the Order Online button, or browse the full menu first.

FAQs

Is Two Boots one of the affordable restaurants in the West Village?

We do not rank ourselves, but a slice shop is a naturally wallet-friendly way to eat out because you choose the portion. You can order a single slice, split a whole pie with friends, or stretch a pie with shareables like Garlic Knots and sliders, which keeps a group meal easy on the wallet.

What size pie should a group order?

Many menu pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes. A 10″ pie suits two people, a 14″ pie works for three or four, and an 18″ pie with a side or two anchors five or six. Add knots, sliders or a salad instead of an extra pie.

What are Bombinis?

Bombinis are savory Cajun hand pies, available in Small and Large at our Manhattan locations only, including West Village. They are easy to share and easy to eat on the go, which makes them a good fit for a walk down Bleecker Street or along the Hudson.

Can a vegan and a meat-eater share one order?

Yes. Our vegan pies use Daiya non-dairy cheese, and options like V for Vegan, Vegan Larry Tate and Earth Mother sit on the same menu as Cajun meat pies like The Bayou Beast. Add the Vegan Calzone or the vegan House Salad and the whole table is covered in one order.

Does Two Boots West Village do catering for offices and student groups?

Yes. West Village catering is drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, with packages organized by group size and vegetarian and vegan options, so you never have to guess quantities.

Is the West Village shop open late?

Our West Village location stays open late on weekends, which makes it a regular stop after a night out around Christopher Street. Hours can change, so check the West Village location page before heading over.