You’ve seen the arch, you’ve circled the fountain, and now you want a slice. For pizza near Washington Square Park, walk west. Two Boots West Village sits at 101 7th Ave S, right at Sheridan Square by Christopher St, a short walk from the park’s west side along W 4th St or Washington Pl.
That walk is the whole trick. The blocks right around the park are packed with students, buskers and people taking photos of the arch, and a lot of what’s closest is built for speed rather than for sitting down with a slice you’ll remember. Two Boots bakes Cajun-Italian pies on a crisp cornmeal crust, names them after pop-culture icons, and has been doing it since 1987, when Phil Hartman opened the first shop on Avenue A in the East Village.
This guide is for one reader in particular: an NYU student between classes, or a visitor who just finished the arch-and-fountain loop and is getting hungry. It covers the route, what to order for your plan, and what tends to go wrong. Think of it as a walking plan with a pizza stop built in, not a list of names.
Key Takeaways
- Two Boots West Village (101 7th Ave S, at Sheridan Square) is a short walk west of Washington Square Park along W 4th St or Washington Pl.
- Grab a slice to go if you’re heading back to the park; order a whole pie if a group wants to sit down.
- The West Village shop carries Bombinis, savory Cajun hand pies sold only at the Manhattan locations, plus a full Daiya vegan lineup.
- Christopher Park and the Stonewall National Monument are steps from the door, so the walk west doubles as a second stop.
Check Out Our Menu!
Pizza Near Washington Square Park: The Walk West to Sheridan Square
Leave the park from its west side and head west on W 4th St or Washington Pl; both bring you across 6th Ave and into Sheridan Square, where Two Boots sits on 7th Ave South. It’s a short walk, flat the whole way, and you won’t need a map once you’ve crossed 6th Ave. The wide, angled crossing of 7th Ave South is your sign you’ve made it.
W 4th St is the livelier option. It runs past shops and the basketball courts near the West 4th St subway station, then angles toward Sheridan Square. Washington Pl is a little quieter and more residential, which is nice if you’re walking with a group and want to talk.
Either way, you’ll know you’ve arrived when the streets start meeting at odd angles. That’s Sheridan Square, where 7th Ave South, W 4th St, Christopher St and Grove St all come together. Two Boots is at 101 7th Ave S.
If you’re coming from somewhere else, the Christopher St–Sheridan Sq stop on the 1 train lets you out right by the shop.
From the West 4th St station, you’re already more than halfway there.
Which side of the park should you leave from?
The west side. If you’re standing under the arch at the foot of Fifth Avenue, you’re on the north edge, so cut across past the fountain toward the west and exit there. Leaving from the east side adds a lot of extra blocks for no reason.
What to Order Near Washington Square Park, Depending on Your Plan
The right order depends on what you’re doing next: heading back to sit by the fountain, eating at the shop, or carrying pies to a dorm or apartment. Our firm view is that a pair of slices beats a whole pie for one or two people going back to the park, because a pie box is awkward on a bench and a slice is meant to be eaten standing up anyway.
| Your plan | What to order | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Solo, back to the park bench | Two different slices | You get two flavors and nothing to carry home |
| Two friends after class | A whole pie, half-and-half if you can’t agree | Settles the debate and is easy to share at the shop |
| Quick snack while walking | Bombinis | Hand pies travel well and need no plate |
| Study group back at a dorm | Two or three pies plus Garlic Knots | Covers different tastes and gives people something to pick at |
| Mixed vegan and non-vegan group | One Daiya vegan pie alongside a classic | Nobody ends up eating only the crust |
| Visitor seeing Stonewall next | A slice now, a second one after | Short stops, no leftovers to manage |
A few things go wrong here more than you’d think. The first is arriving starving and ordering a whole pie for one person to “take back to the park.” It never fits on a bench, and the last slices get cold before you get to them.
The second is ordering for a group without asking about vegan or vegetarian eaters. In a crowd of NYU students, there’s almost always one. Two Boots has a full vegan list, so just ask before you order.
The third is carrying hot pies a long way in the cold. If home is more than a few blocks away, think about pickup timing or catering instead of walking boxes across the Village. Cornmeal crust stays crisp, but it isn’t magic.
The Two Boots Lineup for a Village Crowd
For a first visit, start with a Cajun-leaning pie and a classic, then let the group fight over the rest. Every pie at Two Boots is named after a cultural figure, and each has a backstory, so ordering is half the fun.
| Pie | What’s on it | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| The Bayou Beast | Spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, mozzarella (marked spicy on the menu) | First-timers who want the full Cajun side |
| Grandma Bess | Organic San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil, Parmigiano, mozzarella on a thin, square Sicilian crust | Anyone who wants a classic tomato-forward slice |
| Cleopatra Jones | Sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions, mozzarella | Meat eaters who aren’t after heat |
| The Buckminster | Marinara on top, organic spinach, roasted garlic, parmigiano, provolone, mozzarella | Vegetarians who like garlic |
| V for Vegan | Daiya non-dairy cheese, from the vegan lineup | Plant-based eaters |
| The Meg | Provolone, parmigiano, ricotta, mozzarella, roasted garlic, oregano (a very white pie) | Cheese lovers who skip tomato |
| Mr. Pink | Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella | People who want Cajun flavor with no jalapeños |
The cornmeal crust is the thread running through all of them. It’s crisp, with a texture you’ll notice on the first bite, and it holds up well when you’re eating standing outside. You’ll find it under every pie on this list, vegan ones included.

Bombinis: the Manhattan-only snack
Bombinis are savory Cajun hand pies, and they’re only at the Manhattan shops, which includes West Village. They’re the right call if you want something to eat on the walk back east toward the park. Grab a couple for the walk and save a slice for the bench.
Garlic Knots and sliders
Garlic Knots come three to an order. The Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm (made with andouille meatballs) and Eggplant Parm sliders come on house-made garlic knots, which makes them a good side for a group that’s already sharing pies.
Vegan options
The vegan list uses Daiya non-dairy cheese: V for Vegan, Earth Mother (marinara, no cheese), The VCBGB, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink, plus a Vegan Calzone. That’s a lot of choice for vegan pizza in the West Village, so a plant-based friend doesn’t have to settle for a single option.
Around Sheridan Square: Stonewall, Christopher Park and Bleecker St
The shop’s corner of the Village is full of history. Christopher Park, right by Sheridan Square, is part of the Stonewall National Monument, managed by the National Park Service. Many visitors walk over from Washington Square Park specifically to see it.
That makes Two Boots an easy add to a Village walking day: see the arch and fountain, walk west, eat, then cross to Christopher Park.
Christopher St runs right past the shop toward the Hudson, and it’s lined with old storefronts and small shops. Bleecker St is a block or two away and is one of the Village’s main browsing streets. If you’re a visitor, a loop of Washington Square Park, Christopher Park and Bleecker St, with a pizza stop at Sheridan Square, covers a lot of ground without feeling rushed. If your group browses slowly, shop first and eat last.
For NYU students, this corner is a change of scene. It’s close enough to get to between things, and far enough from campus that you might not run into your whole seminar in line.
The Village has always had a counterculture streak, and so has Two Boots. The original shop opened in 1987 among the East Village’s punk and arts crowd, and that same irreverent attitude carries into pies named after Tony Clifton and Mel Cooley.
Can You Bring Pizza Into Washington Square Park?
People eat in the park all the time, and a slice on a bench by the fountain is a very normal New York afternoon. For the rules on food, events and park use, check the Washington Square Park page from NYC Parks, which is the official source.
What we can tell you is how to make it go well. Slices travel better than whole pies, a pie box won’t balance on a bench, and you’ll want napkins. Take your trash with you or use the park’s bins.
If the park is crowded, which it often is on a warm weekend, eating at the shop and walking back afterward is less stressful than hunting for a free spot with a hot box.
Pizza for Groups and Events Near NYU
For anything bigger than a handful of friends, use catering instead of carrying stacks of boxes across the Village. Two Boots West Village catering is drop-off delivery, with packages built around group size, and it needs 24 to 48 hours’ notice.
That fits student clubs, study-group finals nights, small office lunches and apartment parties in the neighborhood. A good rule: plan one vegan pie for every table of mixed eaters, and add Garlic Knots so people have something to grab while the pies get passed around.
Don’t wait until the afternoon of the event to call, because the notice window is real and a last-minute order puts you back to carrying boxes yourself.
Late nights on the weekend
The West Village shop is a late-night stop on weekends, so a slice after a night out in the Village is on the table. Check the location page for current hours before you go.
Plan Your Pizza Stop Near Washington Square Park
The plan is simple: finish at the arch and fountain, leave the park on its west side, and walk W 4th St or Washington Pl to Sheridan Square. That’s your pizza near Washington Square Park, with Stonewall and Christopher Park waiting across the street when you’re done.
If you’re torn on what to get, start with one Bayou Beast slice and one Grandma Bess slice and decide from there. Get directions and details on the Two Boots West Village location page, and if you want more ideas for the neighborhood, read our earlier guide to pizza near the West Village.
FAQs
Is Two Boots good for a quick lunch between NYU classes?
Yes, as long as you order slices instead of a whole pie. Slices are the fastest way in and out, and the walk from the west side of the park is short enough to fit into a break between classes. Eat at the shop if you can, then walk back with time to spare.
Can I order ahead for pickup at Two Boots West Village?
Two Boots takes online orders through Toast. Start from the West Village location page and check that the order is going to the 7th Ave South shop before you pay. Ordering ahead is the easiest way to skip waiting when you’re on a schedule, especially if you’re picking up several pies for a group.
Does Two Boots West Village have a gluten-free crust?
No gluten-free crust is listed on the Two Boots menu. The menu does list a Gluten-Free Brownie for dessert, so ask at the counter about current options before you order if you’re avoiding gluten.
What’s a good pie for someone who doesn’t like spicy food?
Grandma Bess, The Buckminster, Cleopatra Jones, The Meg and Mr. Pink all skip the jalapeños. The spicy items are marked on the menu, so anything without that mark is a safe pick for a cautious eater.
What should kids order at Two Boots?
The Pizza Face, a kid-friendly face pie that comes in a small size only, is a good pick for families coming over from Washington Square Park who want something simple for younger eaters.
Why is it called Two Boots?
The name comes from the two “boots” of Italy and Louisiana, which is also why the menu mixes Italian pizza traditions with New Orleans Cajun flavors like crawfish and andouille.
