Nashville has a reputation for big nights, and big nights have a way of emptying a wallet before the second chorus. If you’re hunting for affordable restaurants Nashville locals and visitors can lean on, here’s a simple answer: a slice-and-share pizza shop is one of the most wallet-friendly ways to eat out in Midtown. At Two Boots, 1925 Broadway, you can grab a slice, split a whole pie across a table, and stretch the order with knots and salads so everyone leaves full.

Most of the lists ranking for this search are round-ups of twenty places with price tags attached. Handy, but they don’t tell you how to order. This guide does. We’re the only Two Boots outside New York and New Jersey, so think of it as a field manual for getting New York pizza in Music City, and getting a lot of it, without turning dinner into a financial event.

Key Takeaways

  • A slice shop is a smart, affordable way to eat in Midtown: order by the slice for one, or split a whole pie (10″, 14″ or 18″ on many items) across a group.
  • Shareable sides like Garlic Knots, sliders on house-made garlic knots, calzones and a House or Caesar salad stretch one order across more people.
  • Two Boots sits at 1925 Broadway, close to Vanderbilt, Music Row and Centennial Park, so a pie pairs easily with a no-cost afternoon outside.
  • For office lunches, student clubs and parties, Nashville catering is drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice and packages by group size.

Check Out Our Menu!

Why a Slice Shop Belongs on Your Affordable Restaurants Nashville List

Value isn’t only about the number on a receipt. It’s about how full you are, how many people you fed, and whether there’s something left for tomorrow’s lunch. Pizza is built for that math, which is why a neighborhood slice shop earns a spot on any list of affordable restaurants in Nashville.

Here’s what makes the format easy on the wallet:

You control the size of the order. Solo and just hungry-ish? A slice. Two friends? A small pie. A whole study group? An 18″ pie and some knots. You pay for what you need, not a fixed plate per person.

Everything lands in the middle of the table. Sharing is the oldest spend-smart move in dining out. One big pie split six ways goes further than six separate entrées, and nobody’s stuck with a dish they regret.

Leftovers travel. A box of cold pizza is a respected breakfast in dorm rooms all over Midtown. Order a little extra and lunch is handled.

And because our pies blend New York pizza with New Orleans Cajun flavors, a value meal doesn’t mean a boring one. Two Boots started in 1987 on Avenue A in Manhattan’s East Village, named for the two boot-shaped places on the map, Italy and Louisiana. That means crawfish and andouille on one pie and Grandma-style San Marzano on the next, all on a crisp cornmeal crust.

Slice, Small or 18 Inches? Sizing an Order for Your Group

The single biggest way to spend smart at a pizza shop is to order the right size. Too small and you’re back in line. Too big and you’re carrying half a pie down Broadway (not the worst problem, honestly).

On our menu, many pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes, and you can also order by the slice. Use this table as a starting point. Appetites vary, so a hungry crowd of college students might bump up a size.

Who’s eating What to order Why it works
Just you, between classes A slice or two Fast, filling, no commitment
Two people on a casual date One 14″ pie to share Split one order instead of two
Three or four friends One 18″ pie plus Garlic Knots (3) One big pie, one shared side
Five or six roommates Two 18″ pies with different styles, plus a House Salad Variety without everyone ordering separately
Small kid plus adults Pizza Face (small only) plus one 14″ pie The kid gets their own pie, adults share
Study group or club meeting Two or three 18″ pies, sliders, cookies Covers vegans, meat eaters and a sweet tooth

A couple of tips from the counter:

Go big and share. For groups of three or more, splitting one larger pie usually beats everyone ordering their own small.

Mix one adventurous pie with one safe pie. The Bayou Beast (spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, marked spicy on the menu) for the Cajun-curious, and a Grandma Bess or a plain cheese for everyone else.

Build your own when the group is picky. Create Your Pizza starts with cheese, and you add only what you want. It’s the least-waste way to feed someone who picks off toppings.

Shareables That Stretch an Order Further

Here’s the trick a lot of people miss: a side or two turns one pie into a meal for more people. Knots, sliders and salads fill the gaps between slices, and dippers turn the crust everybody leaves behind into its own course.

Shareable What it is How it stretches the order
Garlic Knots (3) Classic house garlic knots An easy add-on that fills out a pie for one more person
Hot Knots (3) Knots doused in jalapeño pesto, marked spicy For the heat fans, so the pie can stay mild
Chicken Parm sliders Served on house-made garlic knots A heartier bite for the hungriest person at the table
Meatball Parm sliders Andouille meatballs on garlic knots The Cajun side of the menu in slider form
Eggplant Parm sliders Vegetarian sliders on garlic knots Meat-free filler that still feels substantial
Classic Calzone or Vegan Calzone Folded and baked A whole extra “pie” in a different shape
House Salad (vegan) or Caesar Salad Greens for the table Adds a lighter course so the pizza goes further
Dippers Blue Cheese, Cajun Ranch, Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto, Basil Pesto Makes crusts worth finishing instead of tossing

The dippers deserve their own moment. A side of Cajun Ranch or Sweet Red Pepper Pesto means nobody abandons their crust, which is basically eating more of what you already ordered. That’s value. If knots are your love language, our earlier post on garlic knots in Nashville goes deep on how this New York side dish landed in Music City.

To round it out, desserts include a house-baked chocolate chip cookie and a Gluten-Free Brownie. For drinks, the menu lists Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke or Pepsi, and water.

Low-Cost Afternoons in Midtown, Then a Pie on Broadway

The most wallet-friendly part of a good day out in Nashville is often everything around the meal. Midtown is packed with places to wander that cost little or nothing, and 1925 Broadway sits right in the middle of them.

Centennial Park. Head west up West End Avenue and you reach Centennial Park, the city’s big central green space. Walking the paths, people-watching by the lake and spreading out a blanket on the lawn are all on the house. The park’s centerpiece is the Parthenon, a full-scale replica of the Greek temple that now operates as an art museum. Even from outside, it’s a showstopper and a solid photo backdrop. The park dates back to the 1897 Tennessee Centennial Exposition, which is a good trivia card to play over a slice.

Vanderbilt’s campus. The leafy grounds of Vanderbilt University are a pleasant walk for students, visiting parents and anyone who likes old trees and brick buildings. Students, this is your reminder that the dining hall isn’t the only option between classes. A slice or a split pie with your roommates is an easy, low-key way to eat off campus.

Music Row. Just southeast of Midtown, Music Row is where a big share of the country music business has worked for decades. Strolling past the studios, publishers and label offices costs nothing, and you never know which old house hides a recording room.

A pizza picnic. Grab a whole pie to go, walk it over to the park, and you’ve got dinner with a view. It’s one of the simplest spend-smart moves in town.

Feeding a Crowd: Offices, Student Groups and Parties

Group meals are where spending can spiral: one person orders separately, another needs something special, and suddenly the office lunch costs more than the project. Ordering pizza for the whole group in one go is a cleaner, more affordable approach.

Our Nashville catering page is built for this. Catering is a drop-off delivery service, it needs 24 to 48 hours’ notice, and packages are organized by group size, with vegetarian and vegan options available. That suits:

  • Midtown and Music Row offices planning a team lunch or a release-day celebration.
  • Vanderbilt student organizations feeding a club meeting or a study night.
  • Birthday parties and watch parties where you want one order, one delivery and no cooking.

A simple, wallet-friendly group order looks like this:

  1. One crowd-pleaser pie: cheese or Grandma Bess.
  2. One meat pie: Cleopatra Jones (sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions) or Mr. Pink (Creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic).
  3. One vegan pie: V for Vegan or Vegan Cleo, both made with Daiya.
  4. One for the adventurous: The Bayou Beast or The Dude, our Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie.
  5. Sides: Garlic Knots, a House Salad, and cookies for the finish.

For smaller orders, the Order Online button on our location page handles takeout.

Mixed Tables: Vegans, Meat Lovers and Kids on One Order

One of the sneakiest ways a night out gets expensive is when a group can’t agree and splits up, or orders from three different places. A menu that covers everybody keeps the group (and the bill) together.

Vegans get a real lineup. Our vegan pies are made with Daiya non-dairy cheese: V for Vegan, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate, Vegan Mr. Pink and The VCBGB. Earth Mother skips cheese entirely. There’s a Vegan Calzone too, and the House Salad is vegan.

Meat lovers have options with a backstory. The Newman (sopressata and sweet Italian sausage on a white pie) and Big Maybelle (Creole chicken, Zoe’s pepperoni, fresh garlic) are both on the menu.

Kids are covered. Pizza Face comes in a small size only and is our kid-friendly face pie. Create Your Pizza works for the “just cheese” crowd.

Twins make sharing easy. Order a regular pie and its vegan twin, like Larry Tate and Vegan Larry Tate, or Cleopatra Jones and Vegan Cleo. Everyone gets the same flavor, nobody orders a separate meal, and the table stays one table.

A note on gluten: our menu doesn’t list a gluten-free crust. The Gluten-Free Brownie is the gluten-free item on the menu, so if anyone has an allergy, ask the staff about ingredients before ordering.

Conclusion

Eating affordably in Nashville doesn’t mean settling. It means ordering smart: a slice when you’re solo, a big pie split across the table when you’re not, knots and salads to stretch it, dippers so no crust goes to waste, and catering when the whole office or club needs feeding. Add a free afternoon at Centennial Park or a walk around Vanderbilt, and you’ve got a full Midtown day that’s easy on the wallet.

Come find New York pizza in Music City at 1925 Broadway. Plan your visit or order from our Nashville location page.

FAQs

Is Two Boots a good option for affordable food in Nashville?

Yes, especially if you share. You can order by the slice or by the whole pie, and many pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes, so splitting a larger pie across a group is an easy way to keep a meal wallet-friendly. Sides like Garlic Knots and a House Salad help one order feed more people.

What size pizza should I order for a group?

As a starting point, a 14″ pie suits two people and an 18″ pie plus Garlic Knots suits three or four. For five or six, try two 18″ pies with different toppings and a salad. Hungry college appetites may need to go up a size, so plan with your group in mind.

Can I get pizza by the slice at the Nashville location?

Yes. You can order by the slice or by the whole pie, so a quick solo lunch near Vanderbilt and a big group dinner both work from the same menu.

What’s near Two Boots Nashville to do before or after eating?

Two Boots is at 1925 Broadway in Midtown. Centennial Park and the Parthenon are a short trip west, Vanderbilt’s campus is close by, and Music Row is just southeast. A to-go pie makes an easy picnic in the park.

Do you have vegan options so a mixed group can share one order?

Yes. Vegan pies with Daiya include V for Vegan, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan and Vegan Larry Tate, and Earth Mother skips cheese. The Vegan Calzone and House Salad are vegan too, so plant-based eaters can share the same order as everyone else.

How does catering work for an office or student group in Nashville?

Our Nashville catering is a drop-off delivery service that needs 24 to 48 hours’ notice. Packages are organized by group size, with vegetarian and vegan options, which suits office lunches, club meetings and parties.