You have two tickets, a curtain time and an empty stomach. Two Boots Upper West Side sits at 70 W 71st St, just off Columbus Ave, and Lincoln Center is a few blocks straight down that same avenue. If you’re hunting for pizza near Lincoln Center that you can actually fit between work and the first act, that short walk is the whole trick: eat on 71st, then stroll south with time to spare.

This isn’t a list of twenty restaurants with one line each. It’s a plan from the shop’s side of the counter: how the walk works, what to order when the clock matters, what to carry and what to leave, and how the rest of the neighborhood (the Beacon Theatre, the Natural History Museum, Central Park West) fits around a slice.

Our pick for most couples on a show night? Two slices each and an order of Garlic Knots, eaten at the counter. More on why below.

Key Takeaways

  • Two Boots Upper West Side is at 70 W 71st St, a few blocks north of Lincoln Center, and Columbus Ave connects the two in a straight line.
  • Before a performance, slices beat a whole pie: they come out fast, you can stop when you’re full, and nothing needs a box.
  • Bombinis, our savory Cajun hand pies, are sold only at the Manhattan shops, so the Upper West Side is one of the few places to get them.
  • Groups from rehearsal rooms, classrooms or offices nearby can order drop-off catering with 24 to 48 hours’ notice.

Check Out Our Menu!

Pizza Near Lincoln Center: The Columbus Ave Walk

The route between our pizza near Lincoln Center and the campus itself is one of the easiest walks on the Upper West Side: head to the corner of 71st and Columbus, turn south, and keep going. Columbus Ave runs straight down to the Lincoln Center campus, which spreads across the blocks roughly between West 62nd and West 66th Streets between Columbus Ave and Broadway.

That’s a few blocks, all on one avenue, with no turns to remember. Most people do it at a relaxed pace and still arrive before the lobby fills up.

A few practical notes from people who make this walk all the time:

  • Stay on Columbus. Broadway angles across the grid near 65th, and it’s easy to drift onto it and lose track of where you are. Columbus keeps the numbered streets ticking down in order.
  • Cross at the light near 66th. The crossings close to the campus get crowded right before a performance, so give yourself a minute there.
  • Coming by subway instead? The 1 train stops at 66th St–Lincoln Center, and the B and C stop at 72nd St on Central Park West, a block from our door. Some people ride to 72nd, eat, then walk down.

Eating first and walking south means the walk is the last thing you do, and you arrive without a pizza box or crumbs on your coat.

Check your venue’s door time on the Lincoln Center site before you plan backward from it. Different halls on the campus seat people at different times, and that’s the number your dinner should hang on.

What to Order for Your Plan

The right order for pizza near Lincoln Center depends less on appetite and more on how much time sits between you and your seat. Here’s how we’d split it.

Your plan What to order Why it works
Couple, show tonight, tight window Two slices each plus Garlic Knots to share Slices come out fast, and knots fill the gap without a second round
Couple, show tonight, relaxed evening A 10″ pie (Grandma Bess or Cleopatra Jones) A small pie is enough for two and still feels like a sit-down dinner
Student between classes or rehearsals One slice and a Bombini Filling, easy to eat on the move, nothing to carry back
Family after the Natural History Museum A 14″ or 18″ pie plus a Pizza Face for the youngest One shared order, and the kid gets a pie that’s theirs
Friends meeting before the Beacon Theatre Mixed slices so everyone tries something different Nobody has to agree on one pie
Post-show, heading home A pie to go Eat it at home while you argue about the second act

One position we’ll stand behind: don’t order a whole 18″ pie before a show for two people. It’s a lot of pizza, it takes longer than a couple of slices, and you can’t bring the leftovers into a concert hall. Eat light now, come back for the big pie another night.

The other common mistake is arriving starving with twenty minutes to go. Slices handle that well. A pie built from scratch with five toppings doesn’t.

If you’d rather sit and linger, the 10″ pie is the compromise: a real dinner, sized for two.

Pizza Near Lincoln Center

The Menu Lineup for a Pre-Show Crowd

Pre-show orders work best when the toppings are flavorful but not heavy, and a few pies on our menu suit that brief better than others. All of them come on our cornmeal crust, which stays crisp and holds up when you’re eating with one eye on the time.

Pie What’s on it Who it suits
Grandma Bess Organic San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil, Parmigiano and mozzarella on a thin, square Sicilian crust Anyone who wants something light and classic before a long performance
Cleopatra Jones Sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions, mozzarella The friend who wants something hearty that still eats neatly
Tony Clifton Wild mushrooms, vidalia onions, sweet red pepper pesto, mozzarella Vegetarians who want more than plain cheese
The Bayou Beast Spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, mozzarella (marked spicy) The Cajun-curious who like some heat
Larry Tate Organic spinach, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, white pie A lighter white pie for someone avoiding red sauce
V for Vegan Our vegan pie with Daiya non-dairy cheese Plant-based eaters, and there are plenty of other vegan pies too
Big Maybelle Creole chicken, Zoe’s pepperoni, fresh garlic, white pie Someone who wants protein without heat

Then there are the Bombinis, our savory Cajun hand pies. They’re only on the menu at our Manhattan locations, and they’re made for exactly this kind of evening: one in hand, a short walk, no plate required.

A word on garlic. Several of our pies lean into it (Larry Tate, Big Maybelle, Grandma Bess), and if you’re about to sit shoulder to shoulder in a theater, that’s worth a thought. We’re not telling you to skip it. We’re just saying the Cleopatra Jones exists.

Vegan in the group? The V for Vegan, Earth Mother, Vegan Cleo and Super Vegan all use Daiya cheese (Earth Mother skips cheese entirely). A vegan and a meat eater can split an order of slices and both eat well. For the full list, see the menu.

The Blocks Around Us: Beacon Theatre, the Museum and Central Park West

Lincoln Center is the big draw to the south, but our corner of the Upper West Side pulls people in from several directions on any given evening. West 71st Street sits in the middle of it all.

To the west, the Beacon Theatre is on Broadway in the low 70s, close enough that a pre-concert slice is an easy add. Concert crowds tend to want something quick and filling, and they rarely want to carry anything into the venue, so slices and Bombinis are the usual move.

To the east is Central Park West, one block over. On a nice afternoon, people grab a pie to go and head into the park. On a cold one, they come in from the park and eat at the counter.

Up at 79th Street and Central Park West, the American Museum of Natural History brings families through the neighborhood all day. After a few hours of dinosaurs and dioramas, kids are tired and hungry at the same time, which is a tough combination. A short walk south on Central Park West and a turn onto 71st gets you here, and a shared pie plus a Pizza Face is a reliable way to end the outing without a meltdown. We wrote more about that crowd in our older guide to pizza near the UWS.

Further south, past Lincoln Center, is Columbus Circle. Coming up from Midtown, you can walk north on Columbus, pass the campus, and land at our door.

And then there are the students. Juilliard is part of the Lincoln Center campus, and Fordham’s Lincoln Center campus sits just south of it. Rehearsal schedules don’t care about dinner, so a slice and a Bombini between sessions is a common order here.

Can You Bring Pizza Into a Lincoln Center Performance?

The short answer is that we can’t speak for the venues, so check the rules for your specific hall on its own site before you plan to carry food in. Policies vary by venue and by event, and they change.

What we can tell you is the plan that never runs into that problem: eat first, at our counter, and walk down with your hands free. Pizza is at its best a few minutes out of the oven anyway, and a box of slices that’s been sitting under a seat for two hours is nobody’s idea of a treat.

If you want pizza after the show instead, order a pie to go on your way back up Columbus and eat it at home.

Feeding a Rehearsal, a Class or a Crew

For groups, the smart move is catering, not a dozen people lined up at the counter. Our Upper West Side shop handles drop-off orders with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, and packages are put together by group size.

That suits the people who work and study around Lincoln Center: a rehearsal break for an ensemble, a cast meal before a student performance, a seminar group that’s been in the same room since noon. Mix a few meat pies with a couple of vegan ones and a tray of sliders on garlic knots, and you’ve covered most diets in a single order.

The details, including how to request a quote, are on our Upper West Side catering page.

Here’s how we’d think about the order for a typical group.

Group Suggested mix Tip
Small rehearsal break (6–10 people) Two 18″ pies, one meat and one veggie, plus Garlic Knots Knots keep people going if the break runs long
Class or seminar (15–25 people) A spread of meat, veggie and vegan pies plus sliders Keep the vegan pies on their own end of the table
Cast or crew meal Pies plus Caesar or House salads Salads stretch the order and give people something lighter before a performance

Don’t wait until the day of. Twenty-four hours is the minimum, and for a big group or a busy week, give us the full 48.

Plan Your Pizza Stop Near Lincoln Center

The plan is simple: eat on 71st, walk down Columbus, take your seat with time to spare. For a couple with tickets, that means two slices each and a shared order of Garlic Knots. For a family coming from the museum, it means one big pie and a Pizza Face. And for students working around the campus, a Bombini will get you through the evening.

When you want pizza near Lincoln Center that fits your night instead of fighting it, find directions and contact details on the Two Boots Upper West Side page, then head over a little earlier than you think you need to.

FAQs

Do I need a reservation at Two Boots Upper West Side before a show?

Most people simply walk in and order. If you’re coming with a large group on a show night, think about catering instead, since a big order takes longer than a few slices.

Is Two Boots a good spot for dinner before a Lincoln Center show with kids?

Yes, and the Pizza Face is the reason. It’s a small, kid-friendly pie with a face on it, and it gives younger children something of their own to eat while the adults share a bigger pie. Add Garlic Knots and most kids are happy.

Where does the name Two Boots come from?

The name comes from the two “boots” of Italy and Louisiana, the two places whose flavors meet on our pies. Two Boots started in 1987 on Avenue A in the East Village, founded by Phil Hartman, and that Cajun-Italian mix still runs through the whole menu, including the Upper West Side.

Are there gluten-free options at the Upper West Side shop?

Our menu doesn’t list a gluten-free crust. There is a Gluten-Free Brownie on the dessert list. If gluten is a serious concern for someone in your party, ask at the counter about how the kitchen handles it before you order.

What drinks can I get with my pizza?

We carry Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas, Hal’s seltzer, Coke, Pepsi and water. On a show night, a Hal’s seltzer or a Sweet Leaf tea is the easy pick to carry down Columbus Ave.

Can I build my own pizza if the specialty pies aren’t quite right?

Yes. The Create Your Pizza option lets you pick your own toppings, which helps when one person in the group wants something plain and another wants everything. You can also pair any pie with dippers like Cajun Ranch, Marinara or Basil Pesto for the crusts.