The Upper East Side has a reputation, and it isn’t for being easy on the wallet. White-tablecloth rooms, tasting menus, the occasional gilded lobby. So when people search for affordable restaurants UES locals actually use, they’re usually asking a simpler question: where can I feed myself, my roommate or my whole family a real meal without the bill becoming the main event?
Our honest answer: a slice-and-share pizza shop is one of the most wallet-friendly ways to eat out in the neighborhood, and Two Boots at 1243 2nd Ave, in the 60s, is built for exactly that kind of night. You can order one slice or a whole pie, split it across a table, stretch it with knots and a salad, and walk out to a free evening in Central Park or along the East River.
This post isn’t a list of twenty places with price tags. It’s a playbook: how to order smart at a neighborhood pizza shop on the Upper East Side, plus the free stuff nearby that turns pizza into a whole outing.
Key Takeaways
- A slice-and-share pizza shop like Two Boots Upper East Side (1243 2nd Ave) lets you order exactly as much as you need, from one slice to an 18″ pie for the table.
- Whole pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes for many items, so splitting a bigger pie across a group is the simplest way to spend smart.
- Garlic Knots, sliders on house-made knots, salads and dippers stretch one order into a full meal, and Bombinis are a Manhattan-only extra.
- For office lunches and parties, our Upper East Side catering offers drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice and packages by group size.
Check Out Our Menu!
The Case for a Slice Shop Among Affordable Restaurants UES Locals Rely On
Value isn’t only about the number on the receipt. It’s about how much control you have over what you order and how far that order goes. A pizza shop gives you more of that control than almost any other kind of restaurant.
You set the portion. Some nights you want one slice on the walk home from the 6 train. Some nights you want a pie for four. A slice shop handles both without making either feel like the wrong choice.
Everything is built to share. A whole pie arrives already cut. Garlic Knots come three to an order. Sliders are easy to halve. Nobody needs to order their own separate entree, which is where restaurant tabs quietly balloon.
Leftovers are a feature. Cold pizza for breakfast is a time-honored New York tradition, and a cornmeal crust holds up in the fridge better than you’d expect. Order a size up, and tomorrow’s lunch is handled.
One menu covers a mixed table. Our pies blend Italian and New Orleans Cajun flavors, with a deep vegan lineup on Daiya non-dairy cheese, so the meat lover, the vegetarian and the vegan can share one order instead of splitting the group across three restaurants.
Two Boots has been feeding mixed tables like that since Phil Hartman opened the first shop on Avenue A in 1987. The name comes from the two “boots” of Italy and Louisiana.
Slice, Small Pie or the Big One: Ordering by Group Size
The smartest move at any pizza shop is matching the order to the group. These are starting points, not rules, because a hungry teenager after a game at John Jay Park counts as roughly two people.
| Who’s eating | What to order | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Just you, on the way home | A slice or two | No commitment, no leftovers, back on the avenue fast |
| Two people, a weeknight | One 14″ pie plus Garlic Knots | Two flavors’ worth of filling with a shareable side |
| Two people, one vegan | A 10″ vegan pie and a 10″ regular pie | Both diets covered without anyone settling |
| Three or four roommates | One 18″ pie plus a House Salad | The big pie is the most efficient way to feed a table |
| A family of four with kids | An 18″ cheese or Create Your Pizza, plus a Pizza Face | Simple base for everyone, a small face pie for the youngest |
| Five to eight friends | Two 18″ pies (one red, one white) plus sliders | Variety without ordering a dozen different things |
| An office team or a party | Catering, ordered 24 to 48 hours ahead | Packages sized to the group, delivered and dropped off |
Create Your Pizza starts with a cheese pie and you add only what you want, which keeps a picky group from ordering four separate things. And one red pie plus one white pie, say a Cleopatra Jones and The Meg, covers a lot of ground.
If you’d rather keep it to slices, our earlier post on pizza by the slice on the Upper East Side walks through the slice side of the counter.
Shareables That Stretch One Order Into a Full Meal
The pie is the anchor. The sides are what turn it into dinner. Here’s what on our menu does the most stretching.
| Shareable | What it is | How it stretches the order |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic Knots (3) | Knots tossed in butter, parsley, garlic and Parmigiano, marinara on the side | Fills the gap while the pie bakes, and kids love them |
| Sliders | Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm (andouille meatballs) or Eggplant Parm on house-made garlic knots | A heartier bite that halves easily between two people |
| Classic Calzone | A folded, filled pie | One person’s dinner, or a split for two light eaters |
| Vegan Calzone | The plant-based version | Gives the vegan at the table their own main |
| House Salad (vegan) or Caesar | Greens alongside the pizza | Makes a smaller pie go further for a group |
| Bombinis (Small or Large) | Savory Cajun hand pies, Manhattan locations only | Portable, self-contained, good for walking to the park |
| Dippers | Blue Cheese, Cajun Ranch, Marinara, Jalapeño Pesto, Sweet Red Pepper Pesto, Basil Pesto | Turn leftover crusts into a second course |
The dipper trick is real. Plenty of people leave the crust. Add a Basil Pesto dipper and suddenly the crust is a course of its own. More of what you ordered actually gets eaten.
Bombinis are the UES advantage. They’re only on the menu at our Manhattan shops (the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side and the West Village), and they travel well, which matters when the plan is a bench overlooking the river.
Finish without a second stop. A house-baked chocolate chip cookie or the Gluten-Free Brownie closes the meal, and Spindrift, Sweet Leaf teas, Boylan sodas and Hal’s seltzer cover drinks.
Free and Low-Cost Upper East Side Outings to Pair With a Pie
Here’s where the Upper East Side surprises people. For a neighborhood with a pricey reputation, some of its finest afternoons cost nothing at all. Pair one with a pie from 2nd Ave and you have a whole day out.
Central Park’s east side. From 2nd Ave in the 60s, it’s a straight walk west to Central Park. Enter on the east side and you’re close to the Pond near the southeast corner, the Mall and its elm canopy, Bethesda Terrace, and Conservatory Water, where model sailboats drift around on weekends. Spread out on a lawn with a pie and you’ve got dinner with a view no restaurant can match.
Carl Schurz Park and the East River. Head northeast to East End Avenue around 86th Street and you’ll find Carl Schurz Park, with lawns, a playground and the riverside promenade along the East River. Gracie Mansion sits inside the park. It’s a classic Upper East Side evening walk, and a couple of Bombinis or a box of knots makes good company.
The Roosevelt Island Tram. Just down 2nd Avenue around 59th and 60th Streets, the Roosevelt Island Tram lifts you over the East River with skyline views usually reserved for observation decks. Grab slices to go before you ride, then picnic on the island and ride back.
Museum Mile on Fifth Avenue. Fifth Avenue’s museums line up a short walk west of the park. Some offer free or pay-what-you-wish times, so check each museum’s own site. The people-watching on the steps is always free.
| Upper East Side outing | What to bring or order after | Why it pairs well |
|---|---|---|
| A lawn in Central Park’s east side | An 18″ pie and a House Salad | Picnic-sized, feeds the whole blanket |
| Evening walk in Carl Schurz Park | Bombinis and Garlic Knots | Portable, easy to eat on a riverside bench |
| Round trip on the Roosevelt Island Tram | Slices to go | Fast to grab before the ride, eaten with a skyline view |
| A Museum Mile afternoon | Grandma Bess and Eggplant Parm sliders | Classic comfort after a lot of walking |
| That’s the formula for spending smart in this neighborhood: one satisfying, shareable order, with the parks, the river and the views supplying the rest of the evening for free. |
Groups, Offices and Parties: Catering That Goes the Distance
Sooner or later, someone on the Upper East Side gets volunteered to feed a crowd: an office lunch, a study group, a building gathering, a birthday at home.
Start with our Upper East Side catering page. Catering is drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, in packages built around group size, with vegetarian and vegan options. Planning ahead beats the last-minute scramble, which is usually when groups overspend.
A simple formula for a group order:
- Build the base. Cheese plus a simple veggie pie like Grandma Bess, on its thin, square Sicilian crust.
- Add one white pie and one vegan pie. The Meg and V for Vegan mean nobody is left out.
- Add one pie with personality. Mr. Pink or The Dude, our Cajun bacon cheeseburger pie.
- Fill the edges. Garlic Knots, sliders and salads stretch further than another whole pie.
- Finish sweet. Cookies and the Gluten-Free Brownie.
For five or six people, skip catering and order a few whole pies online.
Mixed Tables: Vegan, Meat Lovers and Kids in One Order
One sneaky way a group overspends is splitting up: the vegan friend wants one place, the kids another, and one dinner becomes three. Keeping everyone on one order is an underrated value move.
The vegan lane is a full menu. V for Vegan, Earth Mother (marinara, no cheese), The VCBGB, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink, most built on Daiya. A Vegan Cleo next to a Cleopatra Jones lets the table compare notes.
The meat lovers are covered. The Newman, Super Newman, Big Maybelle and The Dude bring the hearty side.
The kids are easy. Pizza Face (small only), a cheese pie, Garlic Knots with marinara and a cookie. Done.
If anyone has a food allergy, ask the staff about ingredients before ordering.
Conclusion
Eating out on the Upper East Side doesn’t have to mean a splurge. The trick is choosing a place where you control the portion, the table can share, and one order covers every kind of eater. That’s what a neighborhood pizza shop does well: a slice on the walk home, an 18″ pie for the roommates, knots and Bombinis for a riverside bench, catering for the office.
Then let the neighborhood do the rest: a lawn in Central Park, a walk through Carl Schurz Park, a ride on the Tram. Come by Two Boots at 1243 2nd Ave, or plan your order from our locations page.
FAQs
What makes a pizza shop one of the more affordable restaurants on the Upper East Side?
You decide exactly how much to order, from a single slice to a whole 18″ pie, and almost everything is designed to share. Splitting a bigger pie across a group, adding knots or a salad, and taking leftovers home all help one order go further than separate entrees at a sit-down restaurant.
What pizza sizes does Two Boots offer?
Many of our pies come in 10″, 14″ and 18″ sizes, and you can also order by the slice. Pizza Face, our kid-friendly face pie, comes in small only. Check the menu page for the sizes available on each item.
What are Bombinis, and can I get them at the Upper East Side shop?
Bombinis are savory Cajun hand pies that come in Small and Large. They’re only on the menu at our Manhattan locations, which are the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side and the West Village, so yes, you can order them on 2nd Ave.
Can a group with vegans and meat eaters share one order?
Yes. Our vegan lineup, mostly made with Daiya non-dairy cheese, includes V for Vegan, Earth Mother, The VCBGB, Vegan Cleo, Super Vegan, Vegan Tony Clifton, Vegan Larry Tate and Vegan Mr. Pink, plus a Vegan Calzone and a vegan House Salad. Pair a vegan pie with a regular one and the whole table eats from the same order.
Does Two Boots Upper East Side cater office lunches and parties?
Yes. Our Upper East Side catering offers drop-off delivery with 24 to 48 hours’ notice, with packages sized by group and vegetarian and vegan options. For a smaller gathering, ordering a few whole pies online also works well.
Is there a loyalty program or gift cards?
Yes. Two Boots has a loyalty program and gift cards through Toast, our online ordering platform. You can find them when you order online.
