Pizza by the Slice Done Right – Only at Two Boots Upper West Side

There’s something sacred about the phrase pizza by the slice in New York City.
It’s not just a way to eat – it’s a way of life. You grab it on your lunch break, after a Broadway show, between errands, or on your way home after the subway doors close. It’s fast, it’s hot, it’s comforting, and it’s uniquely New York.

And nowhere does that tradition come alive quite like the Upper West Side. This neighborhood knows the meaning of comfort food – and the joy of finding that perfect, foldable, flavor-packed slice.

At Two Boots Upper West Side, we take that classic New York tradition and turn it into something extraordinary. Our pizza by the slice is more than just convenient – it’s colorful, Cajun-inspired, and full of character. Every slice tells a story, baked with love, spice, and a little attitude.

So, whether you’re running to Lincoln Center, catching up with friends at Riverside Park, or just craving something satisfying after a long day – stop by Two Boots. Because when it comes to pizza by the slice on the Upper West Side, no one does it quite like we do.

A Slice of New York Tradition

Every New Yorker has their “slice story.” Maybe it’s the first time you ate standing on the sidewalk, juggling a paper plate and a soda. Or maybe it’s your go-to late-night spot after a concert, the one that always hits the spot.

That’s the beauty of pizza by the slice – it’s personal, spontaneous, and universal all at once. You don’t have to plan for it. You just know where to go when the craving hits.

The Upper West Side has always been one of those neighborhoods where pizza means connection – families stopping in after school, friends grabbing a quick bite before a show, students and professionals refueling between classes and meetings.

And Two Boots fits right into that rhythm.

We’re here for the spontaneous lunch breaks, the post-movie munchies, the strolls down Amsterdam Avenue that lead to a warm, cheesy slice that makes the day better.

But what makes our pizza special isn’t just that it’s convenient – it’s that every slice has personality.

Pizza by the Slice – The Two Boots Way

Sure, you can find pizza by the slice on nearly every corner of Manhattan. But not every slice is made with the same love – or the same kick.

At Two Boots, we believe a slice should never feel like an afterthought. It should be just as flavorful, balanced, and memorable as a full pie.

Here’s how we do it:

A Cornmeal Crust That Crunches Back

Our secret weapon is the cornmeal-dusted crust – golden, crispy, and a little rustic. It holds up perfectly under the weight of bold toppings and flavorful sauces. One bite, and you’ll hear that satisfying crunch – the sound every New Yorker recognizes as a great slice.

Sauces with Soul

Our Cajun-Italian roots are what make every Two Boots slice stand out. We don’t just rely on one sauce; we layer flavor like an artist mixes paint. From our classic tomato base with a hint of spice to basil pesto and sweet red pepper pesto, each one adds its own character to the experience.

Toppings That Tell a Story

Every Two Boots pizza has a personality. Our slices are like characters – bold, unique, and full of flavor. You’ll find artichokes, spicy vegan sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic, and vegan cheese melting into harmony. Each combination is crafted with care, giving every slice a signature twist.

Because at Two Boots, pizza by the slice isn’t just a snack – it’s a craft.

Slices That Steal the Show

At Two Boots Upper West Side, we’re known for our creative pies – but when you get them by the slice, the flavor hits even harder. It’s that perfect ratio of crispy crust to gooey topping, that one hot, fresh slice that doesn’t need anything else to make your day.

Here are just a few of our fan favorites that truly shine by the slice:

🍕 Tony Clifton

Smoky, sweet, and a little mysterious – just like its namesake. This slice is loaded with mushrooms, Vidalia onions, and a layer of sweet red pepper pesto that ties it all together. Every bite gives you a perfect mix of sweet and savory with a touch of Southern soul.

🍕 Mr. Pink

Simple. Elegant. Timeless. Fresh plum tomatoes, garlic, and mozzarella come together for a clean, classic flavor that never gets old. It’s the slice that proves sometimes less really is more.

🍕 V for Vegan

The hero of our vegan menu – and a total crowd favorite. It’s loaded with artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil pesto, and Daiya vegan cheese. It’s rich, creamy, and so good you won’t believe it’s plant-based.

🍕 Super Vegan

Big, bold, and beautiful – that’s how we describe the Super Vegan. It’s piled high with broccoli, artichokes, mushrooms, onions, and double pestos. It’s a feast in slice form.

Whether you’re a vegan, vegetarian, or carnivore, every Two Boots slice feels personal – like it was made just for you.

Check Out Our Menu!

Why Pizza by the Slice Just Hits Different on the Upper West Side

The Upper West Side is where tradition meets creativity – and that’s exactly how we make our pizza.

It’s a neighborhood that’s fast-paced but still finds time to slow down for the good stuff. It’s where people appreciate art, community, and good food that feels authentic. That’s what we love about serving here.

When you walk into Two Boots Upper West Side, you’ll see families sharing laughter over slices, students grabbing a quick bite before class, and friends catching up after work. It’s easy, it’s real, and it’s all about connection.

Because pizza by the slice isn’t just food – it’s part of the neighborhood story.

And when you add a little New Orleans spice to that classic New York energy? You get something unforgettable.

Grab a Slice, Stay for the Vibe

Walk into Two Boots Upper West Side, and you’ll feel it immediately – the colors, the music, the warmth.
Our walls are alive with art, our staff greets you like family, and the smell of hot, fresh pizza fills the air.

You can stop in for a quick slice to go or hang out and enjoy the neighborhood atmosphere. Either way, it’s never just a transaction – it’s an experience.

We’re open every day until 10 PM, so whether you’re grabbing dinner before a Lincoln Center show or satisfying a late-night craving, you know exactly where to go.

And the best part? You don’t need to commit to a whole pie to get the full Two Boots experience – just one slice is all it takes.

The Slice That Brings Everyone Together

There’s something beautiful about how pizza by the slice connects people. It’s democratic. It’s humble. You don’t need a reservation, and you don’t need to wait. You just need a craving – and a dollar or two in your pocket.

That’s why we love serving slices. Because it keeps us close to the community – and lets us be part of those small, everyday moments that make New York so special.

At Two Boots, every customer is part of our story – from the regular who knows exactly which slice they want to the tourist who stumbles in and ends up staying for a second.

We’ve seen first dates, family dinners, post-game celebrations, and solo lunches all start with one thing – a slice of Two Boots pizza.

That’s why pizza by the slice is more than convenient. It’s a connection.

A Slice of Inclusivity

At Two Boots, we believe flavor should have no limits – and no one should be left out of the pizza party.
That’s why our menu includes vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options – all made with the same care and creativity as our classics.

Our goal is simple: everyone who walks through our doors should leave full, happy, and ready to come back for another slice.

From the V for Vegan to the Super Vegan and our gluten-free crusts, we make sure every guest finds something that hits the spot. Because pizza isn’t just food – it’s joy. And joy should be for everyone.

Visit Two Boots Upper West Side – Pizza by the Slice, Redefined

So the next time you’re walking through the Upper West Side, hungry for something that tastes like New York but feels like you, come see us at Two Boots.

Grab a slice of Tony Clifton on your lunch break.
Share a Super Vegan with your best friend.
Or just stand by the counter, take that first cheesy bite, and remember what makes NYC pizza so iconic.

Because at the end of the day, pizza by the slice isn’t just about food – it’s about flavor, freedom, and a little bit of magic in every bite.

Order Now!

FAQs – Two Boots Upper West Side