Best Pizza in Brooklyn: What Makes Two Boots a Slice Above the Rest

If there’s one thing Brooklynites can agree on, it’s that pizza is more than food – it’s a way of life. Every neighborhood has its own favorite spot, and every local swears theirs is the best. From corner slices to wood-fired masterpieces, Brooklyn’s pizza scene is full of personality, flavor, and passion.

At Two Boots Park Slope, we’re proud to be part of that story. Nestled in one of Brooklyn’s most vibrant neighborhoods, we’ve spent years crafting pies that celebrate creativity, community, and that signature Two Boots flair.

Our recipe for success is simple – take the bold, spicy soul of New Orleans, mix it with the classic pizza craftsmanship of New York City, and bake it all with love, laughter, and a little attitude.

That’s what makes us one of the best pizza in Brooklyn – not just because of our crust or sauce, but because every slice tells a story.

A Brooklyn Classic with a New Orleans Twist

The name “Two Boots” comes from the shape of Italy and Louisiana, both resembling boots on the map – two worlds that inspired our flavor philosophy. From Italy, we inherited the passion for pizza-making: fresh dough, tangy tomato sauce, and careful craftsmanship. From Louisiana, we borrowed the spice, rhythm, and spirit of New Orleans.

That’s how Two Boots was born – a mashup of two cultures that love good food and great company.

When we opened our Park Slope location, we wanted to capture that same energy. Brooklyn has always been a melting pot of art, food, and people – and so are we. Our walls are colorful, our music’s lively, and our ovens are always hot. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, we promise one thing: every visit feels like home.

What Makes Two Boots the Best Pizza in Brooklyn

We’ll be honest – we didn’t set out to be “the best.” We set out to make pizza that stands out. The kind that surprises you with a crunch, a kick, and a burst of flavor that keeps you coming back.

Here’s what puts Two Boots Park Slope a slice above the rest.

1. The Cornmeal Crust – Crunchy, Golden, and Unmistakable

It starts at the bottom – with our signature cornmeal-dusted crust. This isn’t your average dough. It’s crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and has that slight golden crunch that makes every bite satisfying.

We like to call it the Brooklyn bite with a Southern soul. The cornmeal gives it a rustic texture that pairs perfectly with our Cajun-Italian flavors. It’s sturdy enough to hold the toppings but light enough to keep you reaching for another slice.

Close your eyes, take a bite, and you’ll hear that gentle crunch – proof that the crust alone makes Two Boots unforgettable.

2. Sauces with Soul

Every great pizza begins with the sauce, and ours is made from scratch daily. The base is a slow-simmered tomato sauce seasoned with herbs, garlic, and just a hint of Cajun spice – a nod to our Louisiana roots.

But that’s not the only sauce we use. Two Boots is famous for our basil pesto and sweet red pepper pesto, which add richness and depth to our vegan and specialty pies. Some of our creations even blend multiple sauces for that perfect sweet-spicy-savory harmony.

It’s not just tomato on dough – it’s layers of flavor that dance together.

3. Flavor with Personality

At Two Boots, pizza isn’t just about toppings – it’s about stories. Each pie on our menu is named after a character, a movie, or a cultural icon that’s inspired us. From Mr. Pink to Tony Clifton and The Night Tripper, our pizzas are playful tributes to pop culture, humor, and creativity.

Every slice is a personality: bold, unexpected, and full of life – just like Brooklyn itself.

When people talk about the best pizza in Brooklyn, they’re not just talking about ingredients – they’re talking about the memories, the laughter, and the moments shared around that pizza box.

That’s why we bake flavor with meaning.

4. A Community Staple

Park Slope isn’t just our location – it’s our community. We love the families, students, artists, and professionals who fill our shop every day. We’ve hosted fundraisers, partnered with schools, and catered local events – because we’re more than a pizza place; we’re a part of the neighborhood fabric.

When you walk through our doors, you’re greeted with smiles, laughter, and the smell of hot pizza fresh from the oven. It’s the Brooklyn way – warm, welcoming, and real.

The Menu: Slices That Tell a Story

Now let’s get to the fun part – the pizza itself.

Our Park Slope menu is full of creative pies that blend flavor, texture, and personality. Whether you’re a meat lover, a vegetarian, or proudly vegan, there’s a Two Boots pizza with your name on it.

The Classics with a Twist

The Tony Clifton

This bad boy is all attitude – smoky, sweet, and unforgettable. We load it with mushrooms, Vidalia onions, and sweet red pepper pesto, then top it with creamy mozzarella. The onions caramelize to perfection, giving every bite that irresistible sweet-and-savory punch.

It’s a little rock ’n’ roll, a little comfort food, and 100% Two Boots.

Mr. Pink

Inspired by Tarantino’s iconic character, Mr. Pink is bold, unexpected, and impossible to ignore. We top our golden crust with plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella, and vegan chicken (if you like it plant-based) for that perfect balance of juicy, tangy, and rich.

It’s clean, crisp, and guaranteed to disappear slice by slice.

The Night Tripper

Named after New Orleans’ musical legend Dr. John, this pizza is pure flavor magic. With sun-dried tomatoes, jalapeño pesto, roasted garlic, and ricotta, it’s got the right mix of heat, creaminess, and depth.

A little spicy, a little soulful – this is the pizza equivalent of a jazz solo.

The Newman

Classic, hearty, and satisfying. The Newman combines soppressata, sweet Italian sausage, and mozzarella on our signature cornmeal crust. It’s the kind of pizza that reminds you why you fell in love with New York pizza in the first place – only with that Two Boots kick.

Vegan & Vegetarian Favorites

We believe everyone deserves great pizza – no matter their diet. That’s why our vegan and vegetarian menu is the best pizza in Brooklyn.

V for Vegan

This one’s legendary – and for good reason. Topped with artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, basil pesto, red pepper pesto, and Daiya cheese, it’s rich, creamy, and bursting with freshness. Every bite delivers that perfect combination of herby, tangy, and indulgent.

Vegan or not, this one’s a must-try.

Super Vegan

If you like your pizza fully loaded, this is your slice. With broccoli, artichokes, red onions, mushrooms, basil pesto, red pepper pesto, vegan ricotta, and Daiya cheese, it’s flavor on flavor on flavor.

It’s hearty enough for dinner but light enough to leave you satisfied, not stuffed.

Vegan Night Tripper

This is the plant-based version of our New Orleans favorite. It’s got all the kick of the original – sun-dried tomatoes, roasted garlic, jalapeño pesto, vegan ricotta, and Daiya cheese. Spicy, creamy, and layered with flavor, it’s proof that vegan food can rock your world.

Earth Mother

Simple, rustic, and nourishing. With spinach, mushrooms, roasted peppers, red onions, and marinara, this pie feels like a warm embrace. It’s earthy, colorful, and full of that Brooklyn freshness we all love.

Gluten-Free? We’ve Got You Covered.

We know dietary needs matter. That’s why our gluten-free crusts are light, crispy, and flavorful – a perfect base for any of our signature pies. Whether you’re ordering a Vegan Cleopatra Jones or a Larry Tate, you can enjoy it gluten-free without losing an ounce of taste or texture.

For us, inclusion isn’t a trend – it’s a promise.

Check Out Our Menu!

Inside Two Boots Park Slope – Where Flavor Meets Community

Step inside, and you’ll feel it immediately – the Two Boots vibe.

Our Park Slope space is full of energy and color. Walls covered in pop-art murals, music spilling from the speakers, and the smell of fresh-baked pizza filling the air. It’s lively but laid-back, the kind of place where you can unwind with friends, bring the kids, or enjoy a solo slice after work.

We love this neighborhood. Families stopping by after school, couples on date night, friends catching up over a shared pie – it’s all part of the rhythm of Park Slope. And we’re proud to be one of the best pizza in Brooklyn because of the people who make it feel like home.

Catering and Events – Because Great Pizza Brings People Together

Planning a celebration? A team lunch? A community event? We’ve got you covered.

Two Boots Park Slope offers full pizza catering for gatherings of all sizes. Whether you’re hosting an office meeting, a school fundraiser, or a weekend party, we bring the same bold flavors straight to your table.

Choose from:

• Classic favorites like Tony Clifton and Mr. Pink
• Fully vegan or gluten-free options for inclusive catering
• Family-style salads, sides, and beverages

Same-day catering is often available – just give us a call to confirm timing and delivery. We proudly serve Park Slope and nearby areas like Gowanus, Carroll Gardens, and Prospect Heights.

When it comes to best pizza in Brooklyn, we don’t just deliver food – we deliver flavor, fun, and Two Boots spirit.

Why Brooklyn Loves Two Boots

There’s no shortage of pizza in this city – and that’s exactly why we never stop innovating.

What keeps people coming back to Two Boots Park Slope isn’t just the food (though that’s a big part of it). It’s the energy, the humor, the music, and the community. We’re a local institution that celebrates what makes Brooklyn… Brooklyn.

• We’re artistic. Every pizza tells a story – and our walls do, too.
• We’re inclusive. Vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free – everyone’s welcome.
• We’re family. From toddlers to longtime locals, everyone finds a seat at our table.

That’s why when people search for the best pizza in Brooklyn, they find more than a meal at Two Boots – they find a slice of something bigger.

Visit Two Boots Park Slope – A Slice Above the Rest

So whether you’re a Park Slope regular or finding best pizza in Brooklyn for the first time, stop by and see what all the buzz is about.

Grab a slice, soak up the colors, and taste what makes Two Boots Park Slope a true neighborhood favorite. From our signature Cajun-Italian fusion to our creative vegan offerings, we’re proud to bring something new – and delicious – to the Brooklyn table.

Order online, swing by for takeout, or stay a while and enjoy the music. However you slice it, you’re in for a treat.

Because here at Two Boots, we don’t just make pizza – we make memories.

FAQs About Best Pizza in Brooklyn